HomeMy WebLinkAbout070224 HPC Meeting Minutes
esandro
l
June 4, 2024
moved to
Walter Galitzki
Kathleen
Motion passed
Michael D’A
irtual)
Action Motion:Knoblock approve the minutes. seconded.Vote: unanimously.
v
MINUTES
ABSENT:
In person and
(Kathleen Knoblock
EETING
M
MEMBERS
City Hall
Walter Galitzki
Monica Mader
minutes.
:
LOCATION:
, City Clerk Alyssa Rodrigues
EXCUSED
June 4, 2024
Chair Craig Britton
MEMBERS
p.m.
pm by
007 Kellogg Building window and façade repair at 919
-
0
0
0
:
3:0
3
Marvin Continuing Education Courses
Craig Britton (Chair), Walter Galitzki (Vice Chair),
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMITTEE
moved to approve the
other window companies, window guidelines, and window resources
Senior Planner John McDonagh
une 4, 2024
J
Monica MickHager
minute time limit):
-
START TIME:
(3
007, Kellogg Building window and façade repair 919 Water St. Owner:
:
-
:
PRESENT:
was called to order at
MEMBERS PRESENT:
materials and educational courses regarding windows.
Kathleen Knoblock
July 2, 2024
HPC24Duncan Kellogg
Motion passed unanimously.
a)
TopicCall to Order The meeting Approval of Minutes: Motion:seconded.Vote: Correspondence/Attachments: Senior Planner John McDonagh presented the Marvin Continuing Education Courses which
included Discussion ensued around getting more information from Monica Mader. Public Comment Comment was made about looking at Sierra Pacific as well for windows. Discussion ensued
aroundon City website. Old Business John McDonagh presented the HPC24
DATE:VOTING COUNCIL LIASION:CITY STAFF
Action
applicant
bring back
equally
and
and
reason for standing
historic wood shake
-
Engineer’s report,
leave
secondary home, changing approach
.
epoxy concerns, permit,
historic wood shake roofing with
-
and staff recommendation.
reroofing house, secondary historic home,
Secretary of Interior’s Guidelines.
cost of windows, worth at looking at other
in favor of trying to find something that is not
and
tiered guidelines
concern around changing beyond what should be done,
metal roof.
023, 909 Madison St. Replace non
and
-
painting requirements,
, changing out windows on storefront, fixes to front façade,
review conflict of interest with Monica Mader, applicant will work
need to present plans to HPC,
window information,
Monica Mader’s firm helping with structural matter and if she should
percentage of reuse/recycling of metal roof, color, warranty, historic color
roof alternative that lasts as long as metal, cost issue,
.
, consistent response to applicants,
s
reason for wanting
store front windows, 023, 909 Monroe St. Replace non
-
roof
staff recommendation,
metal
HPC 24standing metal seam Owner/Rep: Janet Burr
explained window replacement.
Kathleen Knoblock moved to approve as presented. Walter Galitzki seconded.
a)
original fabric wood shingles, reroofing of historic structure guidelines,
-
Topic Water St which included site visitwindow provider information, Discussion ensued around recuse, Walter Galitzki subcommittee report, square block look, buildings applying for
historic tax incentives, New Business Discussion ensued around the address being 909 Madison St not 909 Monroe St. John McDonagh presented HPC 24roofing with standing metal seam which
included nonmetal seam, Applicant explained Discussion ensued around metal roofs on other houses, fire concerns, reused material, solar, history of current roof, palette for for secondary
homes, affordable alternatives Motion:
Applicant Discussion ensued around window installment, options, painting, like for like, at second meeting this month, on and come back in two weeks, discuss other concerns with John
McDonagh outside of HPC.
1,
-
Motion passed 2
Action Vote: with Walter Galitzki abstaining.
ing
and
,
provid
roofing to workplan,
adding
pm.
need to be consistent with
review documents from
which included
5:04
.
and
basis,
at
one page summary ready for
HPC
/
and no new committee members
.
on interim
was adjourned
g
adopting
around metal roofs
historic uptown walking tours
and
further conversation with staff
1, with Walter Galitzki abstaining.
-
August 6, 2024
requirements
/
parameters
July special meeting, inventory work, and 2010 inventory.
2024 Workplan continued effort
Motion passed 2
ing
a)
Topic Discussion ensued around all applicants, Vote: Discussion ensued around feedback, balancing act with historic, HPC membershipcreat Other Business John McDonagh presented the
2024 Workplan continued effort something before Council Retreat in July, window replacement and permits, design review for only historic, anecdotal data, code enforcement, roofing permits,
Discussion continued around drafts, updated guidelines, future plans, provide summary page, reviewed Comp Plan, need to do final check off, second revision, Monica, tailor special
valuations to help low income, explore housing on ground floor residential use of historic commercial buildings, explore award system, retreat, Upcoming Meetings: Discussion ensued
around the July 23 special meetingapplications. Adjourn: There being no further business, the meetin