HomeMy WebLinkAbout080624 HPC Meeting Minutes
esandro
l
Monica Mader
irtual)
v
Action Motion: made a motion that the proposed ADU location meets the intent of the language of the HPC by providing visibility to the
Michael D’A
MINUTES
In person and the
(
of
The
process,
014, 1406
-
ABSENT:
EETING
City Hall
, Monica Mader, Craig Britton
M
HPC
the intent
.
Lonnie Mickle
HPC 24
lot lines, committee
-
MEMBERS
A.1
meets
LOCATION:
City Clerk
subdivided
(None)
:
explained
Kathleen Knoblock
being
Building after new business.
Deputy
,
lot
g
EXCUSED
and the
Departure for Location of a New Accessory
presented and
Vice Chair Walter Galitzki–
p.m.
0
MEMBERS
0
pm by
:
7
3
3:0
(None)
Walter Galitzki (Vice Chair),
and applicant
technical term of façade, code, 16ft back from lot,
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMITTEE
considering a fence, one step back from façade,
Senior Planner John McDonagh
014, 1406 Garfield St
ADU precedent cautions,
START TIME:
(None)
-
Monica MickHager
minute time limit):
-
(3
, 2024
(None)
HPC 24
:
:-
PRESENT:
was called to order at
Departure for Location of a New Accessory Structure on site with a Primary Historic
-.
A.1Structure on site with a Primary Historic Residence.Owner: Susan O’Brian and John O’ BrianAgent: Guy Hupy, Guy Hupy Design
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Monica Mader made a motion that the proposed ADU location
August 6
a)
TopicCall to Order The meeting Approval of Minutes:Correspondence/Attachments:Public Comment There was no public comment. Old Business Vice Chair Walter Galitzki asked to add item about
Kellogcommittee agreed. New Business Senior Planner John McDonagh Motion:
Garfield StResidence Discussion ensued around process, location of ADU on property, lots/tax parcels, lot line, setbacks with porch, façade of new building and old building, first departure
request,
DATE:VOTING COUNCIL LIASION:CITY STAFF
r
for a tie
Kathleen
2, Monica Made
Motion failedMotion passed
-
: 2
Action principal façade and that the proposal as submitted by applicant be approved. Kathleen Knoblock seconded. Vote voteand Kathleen Knoblock in favor, Walter Galitzki and Craig Britton
opposed. Motion:Knoblock moved to approve the application as submitted. Walter Galitzki seconded. Vote:unanimously.
024 1440
-
.
purview of HPC.
.
in the
and Kathleen Knoblock in favor, Walter
r
.
presented and explained HPC 24
Departures for Principal Façade alteration and
-
and decision
2, Monica Made
-
2
representative
for a tie vote
what the deal breaker is and what would make the Committee agree.
024, 1404 Lawrence St. 025, 955 Water St.
--
: Guy Hupy Design
t
Departures of Principal Façade alteration and New Additional location onto a
-
New rooftop deck, revised railing, other façade alterations
HPC24New Addition location onto a Secondary Historic Residence (i.e., a new covered front porch entry) Owner: James and Lani BrennonAgenHPC24
Kathleen Knoblock moved to approve the application as submitted. Walter Galitzki
b)c)
Motion failed
Motion passed unanimously.
:
Topic language of the HPC by providing visibility to the principal façade and that the proposal as submitted by applicant be approved. Kathleen Knoblock seconded. Vote
Galitzki and Craig Britton opposed. John McDonagh explained it will go to the Planning and Community Development Director Emma Bolin for administrative review Discussion ensued around
appreciation for applicants and their ADU design Public comment:Josh spoke about In response to public comment, the Committee explained what is Discussion ensued around address being
1440 Lawrence St not 1404 Lawrence St. John McDonagh and applicant Lawrence StSecondary Historic Residence (i.e., a new covered front porch entry) Public comment:Josh spoke about project
being an example and remedy. Discussion ensued around setting precedent, safety issue, and modest exterior change. Motion:seconded. Vote:
by
Monica Mader
Motion passed
)
.
camera off unable to see
Action Motion:moved to approve the applicant’s proposal with no changes as presented. Seconded by member (hand raised but second was acknowledgedchair Vote:unanimously.
5pm
-
025 955 Water
-
of inventory, color
pm.
4
5:0
at
proposal with no changes as
applicant’s
was adjourned
g
, anything will be an improvement to structure, and
lines in future meeting.
camera off unable to see hand raised but second was
g building, no representative, repairs completed, additional
g
place.
fascia board and pleased with proposal.
relevance to HPC
)
.
August 6, 2024
project
, and working on guide
scoring system and maps, Phase II and Phase III, history
by chair
Review of available draft GuidelinesPhases II and III introduction of historic residential inventory Consider Special Meeting date (late August?) to focus on 20204 Workplan items
about
Rep: Trent McKnight, G. Little Construction a.b.c.
Monica Mader moved to approve the
2024 Workplan continued effort to:
Motion passed unanimously.
a)
Topic John McDonagh and applicant representative presented and explained HPC24St New rooftop deck, revised railing, other façade alterations. Public comment:Josh spokebuilding being
an important Discussion ensued around Motion:presented. Seconded by member (acknowledged Vote: Other Business Discussion ensued around Kello2x6’s attached since application concerns,
applications on table for September discussion, glass repair instead of replacement, may revisit replacing storefront glass, order of discussions, special meeting date in August, drafts
of guidelines, resend draft guidelines, August 27, 3special meeting, coding, next steps Upcoming Meetings: Adjourn: There being no further business, the meetin