HomeMy WebLinkAbout061223 Special Session Business Meeting Packet- Added after Meetinguuuuuuullll e t iu ni e lr u" umum"Llvimo g eCIwlli@ 'illimM ''elly t elli@
City Council Presentation
J u n e 12, 2023
R Top,
)3
S i
S11,11,
Meeting Agenda
00 W6corine & P�,,ocess, U�,,-)('Jate
0`111 Site 4-4ysis,
c)'::1 "rr o rin e
c
03 Cl'&lf,Hlf'R,-fl1)�ty �� eecfll--,)ad,,(,,
04U�,,-)date
06
Project Calendar
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL
PRESENTATION 1
PRESENTATION 2
PRESENTATION 3
• Program
C4nceptOesign
Final Report
• Site
Options
OPEN HOUSE 1
OPEN HOUSE 2 _._.
OPEN HOUSE 3
Site Options
Evan's Vista Content
Area: 14 acres
PROS
ol �1"pol'f',,�,AIf1I�.f,i�III'fit
r r ril ill I�i� � iC� :Ul f � I -q -C�I� 1-1,H1 I-
Proximityto Compatible Amenities
Partnership Potential
Timing of Site Decision with this Study
Enhances Adjacent Context
Site Avoids Controversy
Minimizes Impactto Pool Operations
CONS
(")I "1':1 11f /;f ri', to I:� I`, �C, I!1// I,)r 1f�:,
Jeff. Healthcare Context
Area: 0.74 acres
PROS
Proximityto Compatible Amenities
Timing of Site Decision with this Study
Enhances Adjacent Context
Cost Recovery Potential
Site Avoids Controversy
Minimizes Impactto Pool Operations
CONS
.)I II I�i��::-fi i�Ul �� l I q %I Iii -I,Hl IBJ
Location Supports South County Participation
Convenient Access to Bus & Bike Routes
Mtn View Context
Area: 3.9 acres
PROS
'I�il (III I� I If II�i111 ,-'�� .I I!`''✓I ,Il illfj/
111,;to( )I I 111,E /;i I,Iiltl4
Convenient Access to Bus & Bike Routes
Partnership Potential
Timing of Site Decision with this Study
Enhances Adjacent Context
Cost Recovery Potential
Site Avoids Controversy
Minimizes Impactto Pool Operations
CONS
,�, 1(, I ),)'), I',.rh
Location Supports South County Participation
Golf Course Context
Area: 58 acres
PROS
CONS
I I I I II 1 1),, `Joi I "'J0 !I It !I
Its / "lokk, (")I It ")"H: I,('/',;
Location Supports South County Participation
Site Selection - Golf Course Update
f,", 0 tl C E P T 1
RESTORED,
CONCEPT 2
HDf B R I D G 0 L. F < OURSE
CONCEPT I
SPACE POF1, NATURE
CONCEPT 4:
THE COMMONS
Golf Course Test Fit Diagram
PROS:
• Prominence from Kearney
CONS:
• Timing of Golf Course Study
• Interrupts linear park approach
• More public interest in Mountain View
Site Analysis
Site Evaluation Criteria
Evan's Vista
Jeff. Healthcare
Golf Course
Mtn View Corns
Locution Supports South County Participation
Accommodates Building & Parking
„
Proximity to Compatible Amenities
Partnership Potential
Timing Site Decision Study
of with this
Enahnc:es Adjacent Context
Site Avoids. Controversy
------------------------------
________,_ ________,_ _________,
J���
--------------------------------
__ _________ ____________Minimizes
MinimizesImpactto Pool Operations
Prominent Front,age and Visibility
aeaan
Cost Reccavery Potential
Convenient Access to BLAS & Bike Poutes
Impacts to Existing Site Amenities
Coon
Fair
Poor
Community Feedback on Site
4. What is your preferred site:
0 Evan's Vista (14 acres� 253
4�((O Jefferson Heafthcare (1 acre) 86
fo Poft lbwrwsend Golf: Cowse (58 ... 296
4D Mouritain View Commons (3,9 a— 565
Program Elements
- Lap/ Competition Pool
- Recreation Pool
- Whirlpool
- Dry Sauna
- Exterior Splash pad/Child ren's Play Area
- Cardio -Weight Fitness Room
- Multi -Purpose Group Exercise Room
- Classroom/Teaching Kitchen
- Birthday Party Room
- Childcare/Child Watch
- Physical Therapy
, nni,"1 t Jk.ai i (not originally in program options)
Community Feedback on Program
What top 3 amenities would you like to see incorporated into a new aquatic wellness center?
Competition Lap Pool
731
INC�gi
Warm Water Rec Pool
850
Exterior Splash Pad
459
Dry Sauna
469
Whirlpool
612
Community Feedback on Program
What top 5 activities do you most want to take part in at a new aquatics wellness center?
10
Cl nildren s Wa1erp1dy
581
(fw�
Swim I "swils
621
Imm
111
Mter Aerobics
1180
Physical Th�-iapy
341
Recreational Swimiming
975
k��J�J�
Compeintive, Swir-nming 247
�00
Scuba Tcalning 103
yogapilates 273
Imm
111
Dance 119
k��J�J�
Aerobk: fxerdse
�00
Cycling Classes
53
l Chi/Medit,,Lio, 1
129
Soo
SArangth Iraining/Vifnghts
32
&DO
.III atth and Wedhess Classes
173
500
Nutritwon ClassQs
43
400
Ill atthy Cooking Claws
78
200
Ndhday Parties
2 31
100
C Ofl) 91Ll rUVY' M eel i r1g S
7b
Program Options
Base
34,000 sf
Building $15.7M
Sitework $3.9M
;t. Cost $27.8M
Cost $9.8M
Project $37.6M
Option A
40,500 sf
Building $18.OM
Sitework $3.6M
Continaencv* $9.01M
Const. Cost $30.6M
Soft Cost $10.7M
Total Project $41.3M
Option B
45,500 sf
Building
$20.OM
Sitework
$3.4M
Contingency*
$9.7M
Const. Cost
$33.1M
Soft Cost
$11.6M
Total Project $44.7M
*Contingency= Design/Construction Contingency, Escalation, and GC Markup
Option C
53,700 sf
...................................................................................................................
Building $24.5
Sitework
$3.1
Contingency*
$11.4
Const. Cost
$39.0
Soft Cost
$13.7
Total Project $52.7
........................................................................
Community Feedback on Program
Which combination of spaces is your preference for the new Aquatics Center?
4
Aquatics Only 35
10 Aquatics, Group/Strength 17 30
Aquatics, Group/Strength, PT 16 1-
Aquatics, Group/Strength, PT, Gym 36
q
None of the Above 31
Other 18 10
D
Survey 1 Results -1,205 Responses
1. Responders primarily between 35 44 & oveii,, �;'56 years of age
2. Key Amenities: Waii,,irn Wateii,, Z,.ecIli ,,eafloir,, ),oW &
3. Responders primarily from ��),oii towirisrr, ii -id
4. Preferred Site: Voew Coirnirnor"is
S. Activities (1/3 or more of votes):
"�i,, 5wh In ii
2, 5wh In
I 0hfldir�,,,,,,iiYs Wateir�I,,,)Iay
4, Walleir
ii" a II ir�I, II irI, & W4
Survey 2 Results -125 Responses
1. Responders primarily between 35 44 & oveii,, �;'56 years of age
2. Responders primarily from ��),oii towirisrr, ii -id
3. Mountain View site supported by'77%
4. Preferred Program: Even split between Aqj))),aflcs oir,4y, and)),oirirr, of,fl,",irr, N4uove
S. YMCA managing supported by 65%
Community Concerns
• Concern of,tM(,,Jir,,,,�, away fromocaflIy owirirr, dssrr,, s
)),o irnoii,,rr, 'taxes - Take care of what we currently have (ii,,oads, Cherry Street Project)
00 exllleirIsMr, to sotrr, d by our population
• Don't tear down the existing 1flx,d,,,,,rr, rr,
W,,at wflI U,,irr, rnrr, to use the facilities? Taxes? Membership?
s'd,"'irr, w Aqj))),aflcs Ceiriteii,, a ii -i? Not enough discussion / opportunity for voting
• Not a,fj),,,)flIy tii,,air,,qcIIIaii,,rr, ii -it process
Capital Cost Summary
Base
34,000 sf
Building $15.7M
Sitework $3.9M
;t. Cost $27.8M
Cost $9.8M
Project $37.6M
*Contingency= Design/Construction Contingency, Escalation, and GC Markup
Option 3
53,700 sf
Building $24.5M
Sitework
$3.1M
Contingency*
$11.4M
Const. Cost
$39.OM
Soft Cost
$13.7M
Total Project $52.7M
Shore Aquatics Precedent
ACTIVIi YPt 01L
i'
SPA
�� �4a;CLlilors�6
A4` TY'A rV
Ky"IM
Shore Aquatics
30,000 sf
Renovation $6.6M
New/Site
U04A+EN HM L
Contingency*
d
Const. Cost
SIL .I
Escalation**
$10.1M
�ir�•r.K�rrs.
$27.6M
IL,�PII3d4b"
$9.7M
� II t.
.... ....... r
nay
�* (A
FLOOR PLAN
ACTIVIi YPt 01L
i'
SPA
�� �4a;CLlilors�6
A4` TY'A rV
Ky"IM
Shore Aquatics
30,000 sf
Renovation $6.6M
New/Site
$ 7.1M
Contingency*
$3.81VI
Const. Cost
$17.SM
Escalation**
$10.1M
Const. Cost
$27.6M
Soft Cost
$9.7M
Total Project $37.3M
DIFFERENCES:
*„ Mwrv�iw``AI Nota 25 -yard pool
• 20,000sf of Renovation
10,000sfofAddition
Ma.fi�dd
• No visibility into pool
* Contingency includes contractor's
mark-up,salestax, and construction
contingency. No escalation
**Project was designed in 2018 with
construction start in 2019. Escalation
aligns with start -of -construction in
sum mer 2025.
Updated Base Plan (Aquatics) - 29,700sf
Full Build Out with Cardio/Weights + Gym - 40,200sf
Site Plan - Base Plan
Anticipated Required Parking
Existing 1925 Building: 28 stalls
Pecyclery:0 stalls
Existing Gym: 13 stalls
Community Center: 65 stalls
Anticipated Parking: 106 stalls
Provided Parking =123 stalls
On -Street Parking on Blaine St.
Parallel Parking: 28 spaces
Angled Parking: 36 spaces
Site Plan - Full Build Out
Anticipated Required Parking
Existing 192S Building: 28 stalls
Pecyclery:0 stalls
Community Center: 6S stalls
Futurel0.000SFAddition: 22 stalls
Anticipated Parking: 128 stalls
Provided Parking =123 stalls
On -Street Parking on Blaine St.
Parallel Parking: 28 spaces
Angled Parking: 36 spaces
Expression of Community & Place
Building Form & Inspiration
Existing Service Providers
Public/Non-Profit Aquatic & Rec Facilities Private Fitness/Wellness Facilities
1. Wi l liam Shore Me morial Pool& YMCA of Port Angeles
2. YMCAof Sequim
3, Olympic Peninsula YMCA
4, Mountain View Pool
S. Kala Point Clubhouse & Pool
6, Port Ludlow Beach Club
Z Hazelwood Family YMCA
8, Bainbridge Island Aquatic Center
1, S3Training
2. Madrona Mind Body Institute
3, Jen Freeman Pilates
4, AnchorGym
NW Yoga & Fitness
Hand to Hand Fitness
S. Port Townsend Athletic Club
6, Energy Stretch
Z Pilates Gig
43
4
8, Salish Sea Judo
9, Mystic Monkey Yoga
SBO Martial Arts
10. Next Level Athletics
11. Fyzical Therapy & Balance
12. Evergreen Fitness
13. Twister Gym nasties
Pop -Up Movement
14, All Points Pilates
Dancing Sky Studio
Service Areas
Primary
Secondary
Preliminary Capital Cost Summary
Base
29,700 sf
Building
$14.91M
Sitework
$4.1M
Contingency*
$7.91M
Const. Cost
$26.911A
Soft Cost
$9.4111A
Total Project $36.311A
Full Build Out
40,200 sf
*Contingency= Design/Construction Contingency, Escalation, and GC Markup
Building
$20.91M
Sitework
$3.51M
Contingency*
$10.1M
Const. Cost
$34.5111A
Soft Cost
$12.0111A
Total Project $46.5111A
Preliminary Operational Cost Summary
Base
29,700 sf
Expense $1.2M
Revenue $0.45M
**Subsidy $0.72M
Cost Recovery 38%
**Subsidy= Net Annual Operating Cost; Current City Subsidy is $0.40M
Full Build Out
40,200 sf
Expense $2.12M
Revenue $1.37M
**Subsidy $0.75M
Cost Recovery 55%
Public Funding Considerations
Potential funding sources:
• Public Facilities District (PFD) - SaWtax
• Metropolitan Parks District (MPD)- ),rq,,",,,mrty rax
Jefferson Co. PFD sales tax includes some taxa floir',,(� of out -of -community vWtor
PFD combined with an MPD requirestwo votes and more public messaging
• MPD MI m -,(ecessary (and potentially sufficient) for most options.
• MPD District Q rdoir',,(� does most of the IIoea %,/y/
y Hdii,-,(g, on the revenues
• MPD District Q,,"',,rdoii,-,o 2 only adds more tax base
Financial Summary
Base (Aquatics)
$36,309,260
$1,175,166
Full Build Out $46,517,939 $2,120,405
$451,269
$1,368,757
$723,897
$751,648
Design Options - With a n d without PFD
«a
>�
« « /-
«
, _ . :
,.,, ,. ,
� � ` >z:
«z
, >
,» azo e ,a azo z:+r, <r 2
Tax Burden Comparisons
Base (Aquatics) $307
Full Build Out $345
$163
$201
Estimated Year 10 levy rates
Four Counter Propositions
Next Steps
• Based on Council Feedback
• Finalize Design
• Finalize Operations& Funding Approach
• Steering Committee Workshop S —June 16
• Steering Committee Workshop 6 -julys
• Review Draft of Final Report
• Final Funding, Operations& Implementation
• Final Open House 3-July12/13
• Final Council Presentation-July17
• Final Report-July21
Resolution 23 -
RESOLUTION NO. 23-
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PORT TOWNSEND,
WASHINGTON SETTING A PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER A CORRECTIVE
ACTION PLAN FOR THE FORT WORDEN LIFELONG LEARNING CENTER PUBLIC
DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
WHEREAS, the Fort Worden Lifelong Learning Center Public Development Authority
(PDA) is governed by Port Townsend Municipal Code Chapter 2.84; and
WHEREAS, Port Townsend Municipal Code 2.84.115 allows the City Manager or City
Council to intervene and exercise such control as is necessary to correct a PDA deficiency
following a public hearing and notice to the PDA; and
WHEREAS, failure to file an annual report or three consecutive quarterly reports is a
deficiency that allows for a corrective action per PTMC 2.84.115; and
WHEREAS, PTMC 2.84.140(B) requires that the PDA file its annual report with the City
within three months of its fiscal year end; and
WHEREAS, the PDA fiscal year ended on December 31, 2022; and
WHEREAS, the PDA filed its annual report on June 9, 2023, more than sixty days past the
deadline of March 31, 2023;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Port
Townsend, Washington, that a public hearing will be held on July 17, 2023, at 6:00, or shortly
thereafter, in the Port Townsend City Council Chambers to consider possible corrective action for
the Fort Worden Lifelong Learning Center Public Development Authority (PDA). The City
Manager is hereby directed to provide the PDA with notice of this hearing. The PDA Financial
Oversight Committee is directed to formulate a draft corrective action plan for the Council's
consideration at that hearing.
ADOPTED by the City Council of Port Townsend, Washington, at a special meeting
thereof, held this 12th day of June 2023.
Attest:
Alyssa Rodrigues
City Clerk
David J. Faber
Mayor
Approved as to form:
Heidi Greenwood
City Attorney