HomeMy WebLinkAbout102008CITY OF PORT TOWNSEND
CITY COUNCIL
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR SESSION OF OCTOBER 20, 2008
CALL TO ORDER AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The City Council of the City of Port Townsend met in regular session the twentieth
day of October 2008 at 6:30 p.m. in the Port Townsend City Council Chambers of
City Hall, Mayor Michelle Sandoval presiding.
ROLL CALL
Council members present at roll call were Brent Butler, David King, Michelle
Sandoval, George Randels, Catharine Robinson, Laurie Medlicott and Mark Welch.
Staff members present were City Manager David Timmons, City Attorney John
Watts, Finance Director Michael Legarsky, Public Works Director Ken Clow, Public
Safety Analyst Ken Horvath, and City Clerk Pam Koiacy.
CHANGES TO THE AGENDA
Mayor Sandoval stated that the Council would hold a brief executive session at the
end of the meeting, and said that no action would be taken following the session.
PRESENTATION
Main Street Board President Susan Windie and Executive Director Mari Mullen were
present to review Main Street's quarterly report for the Council.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC (consent and non-agenda items)
Jim Fritz regarding attracting visitors and suggestion that the City encourage
videography projects.
Rod Davis introduced himself as the new Executive Director of the Port Townsend
Chamber of Commerce.
Karen Nelson presented an update on the efforts of Make Waves to influence
partners to provide funding to keep the pool open until the end of 2008. She added
that the organization has raised half of its $5,000 pledge which will be provided to
the City at the end of the year pending pool operations continuing through 2008.
She provided written materials for the record.
Mabel Campbell regarding a pending street vacation which affects her property.
City Council Business Meeting Page 1 October 20, 2008
CONSENT AGENDA
Motion; Mr. Randels moved for approval of the following items on the consent
agenda. Mr. Welch seconded.
Approval of Bills, Claims and Warrants: Vouchers 106092 through 106222 (and
EFTS) in the amount of $419, 722.41
Approval of Minutes: October 6, 2008
Vote: Motion carried unanimously, 7-0, by voice vote.
PUBLIC HEARINGS
Mrs. Medlicott proposed that the agenda order of public hearings be reversed
because citizens are present who have interest in Item B. There were no
objections.
Mayor Sandoval read the rules of procedure for public hearings.
STREET VACATION PETITION FOR 15-FOOT WIDE ALLEY LYING NORTH OF
BLOCK 2, POWER ADDITION TO THE CITY OF PORT TOWNSEND
(KENNETH GRAVES)
Mayor Sandoval asked if any Council member had any financial or property interests
in this matter. Mrs. Medlicott stated she is a close personal friend of the Graves
family but has not discussed the issue with them.
John McDonagh, staff planner, reviewed the packet materials regarding Land Use
Permit OS-077 to vacate a 15-foot wide alley. Staff has recommended approval with
the conditions as noted in the Findings and Conclusions dated October 15, 2008.
He added that the petitioners and their surveyor are present to speak and answer
questions.
Michael Anderson, project surveyor, representing Mr. Graves, stated that the
applicant concurred with the conclusions of staff that the vacation should be
approved. He noted that there is a typo in the document (should be "Power"
Addition, not "Powers"). He requested that Condition #3 be modified to remove the
requirement for petitioners to submit a Lot Line Adjustment to merge the vacated
right-of-way into their adjoining land.
Kenneth Graves, petitioner, stated he agrees with Mr. Anderson's comments.
There was no other public comment.
City Council Business Meeting Page 2 October 20, 2008
Staff response: Mr. Watts stated that the lot line adjustment is the City's standard
practice. It involves a relatively minor expense of $250 and serves to merge the
vacated right of way into the adjacent property and provide notice of title to
subsequent owners. He stated that, absent a legislative change that would apply to
all street vacations, he does not recommend deviating from this standard practice.
The Mayor asked if the Council members had any clarifying questions.
Mr. Butler questioned why the Non-Motorized Transportation Advisory Board
recommendation was not included by staff in the approval conditions.
Mr. McDonagh noted that in this case, the right of way in question is not designated
on the Non-Motorized Transportation Plan as a corridor to be preserved and there
are several other opportunities to move around the area on foot.
Ms. Robinson added there are alternative non-street routes in the neighborhood
Ms. Sandoval asked why the adjoining property owners were not provided the
opportunity to acquire half of the alley right of way. Mr. McDonagh stated that the
property owners to the north are in a different plat and are not entitled to property in
another plat.
In answer to a question from Mr. Randels about ownership lying in different plats,
Mr. Watts said that state law and real estate law recognize that the dedication of a
right of way comes from the original grantor and would go back to the grantor's
successor. The City could not override that without condemning the underlying
property.
Ms. Sandoval expressed concerns about the time frames in the first condition
(property purchase within three years of date of approval and appraisal valid for six
months). She noted that given the climate of the real estate market, this may be too
lengthy; she stated that banks are not allowing appraisals or comparables for more
than three months at this time.
Mr. Randels stated he shares this concern and believes a one year time frame
should be adequate; he added that in regard to the action proposed this evening, he
would not want to change the condition the applicant has relied upon. He stated he
does favor reconsidering this time frame as a policy.
Mrs. Medlicott agreed that she would not support changing conditions in the middle
of an individual applicant's process.
Motion: Mr. Welch moved for adoption of Ordinance 2991. Mr, Randels seconded.
City Council Business Meeting Page 3 October 20, 2008
Motion: Mr Butler moved to amend the motion to include retention of the easement
on the vacated alley. Mrs. Medlicott seconded.
Ms. Robinson spoke against the amendment, noting that even though the Non-
Motorized Transportation Plan is outdated, this was an established neighborhood
when the Plan was created and has probably not changed much; in addition, there is
other off-street access so she is not inclined to impose an easement; she also noted
that there wouldn't be much left of the 15-foot width if a trail were included.
Mr. Welch noted it is a steep slope and would be a "trail to nowhere." He does not
support restricting the use of the property in this manner.
Vote on amendment failed unanimously, 0-7.
In response to the time frame issue, the applicant stated that a change in condition
#1 to shorten timeframes for purchase and appraisal would not be a hardship.
Amendment: Ms. Sandoval proposed to amend the ordinance by changing the time
frame for the completion of the property purchase from three years to one year, and
the time for the appraisal to remain valid from six months to three months with a
potential one-time three month extension. The amendment was accepted without
objection.
Vote on motion to approve Findings of Fact and Conclusions of fhe City Counci! as
amended and with typographical errors corrected carried unanimously, 7-0.
Mr. Randels proposed that staff bring forward a policy resolution regarding the time
frame for appraisals and purchases of rights of way in relation to street vacations.
There were no objections.
ORDINANCE 2991
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF PORT TOWNSEND FIXING AND ADOPTING
2009 PROPERTY TAX LEVIES WITH AN INCREASE OF TWENTY SIX AND
SEVEN TENTHS PERCENT (26.70%) FOR THE GENERAL LEVY AND AN
INCREASE OF ONE PERCENT (1%) FOR THE EMERGENCY MEDICAL
SERVICES
Finance Director Michael Legarsky reviewed the packet materials. City Manager
David Timmons provided an estimate of property tax revenues for 2009.
Mr. Legarsky noted that he has contacted Assessor Jack Westerman who does not
have exact valuation figures yet, but had no objection to the Council adopting the
ordinance at this time.
There was no public comment.
City Council Business Meeting Page 4 October 20, 2008
Motion: Ms. Robinson moved for adoption of Ordinance 2991, with correction of fhe
hearing date in first "whereas" to read October 20 rather than October 6. Mrs.
Medlicott seconded. The motion carried unanimously, 7-0, by voice vote.
RECESS
Mayor Sandoval declared a recess at 8:06 p.m. for the purpose of a break.
RECONVENE
The meeting was reconvened at 8:15 p.m.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
ORDINANCE 2993
AN ORDINANCE VACATING A PORTION OF THE 23RD STREET RIGHT-OF-WAY
LYING BETWEEN BLOCKS 13 & 23 OF THE SUPPLEMENTAL PLAT OF O.C.
HASTINGS ADDITION; ESTABLISHING CONDITIONS TO THE STREET
VACATION; AND ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE
Planner John McDonagh reviewed the packet materials, noting the council
preliminarily approved the application for a street vacation on December 13, 2005.
He stated that the applicant, Quimper Unitarian Universalist Fellowship, has met the
conditions of the vacation.
In response to a question from Mr. Randels, Mr. McDonagh stated that the 20 foot
trail easement would be located just to the south of the 23`d Street right of way.
Public comment
Jean Walat, Ward Secretary for the QUUF, stated that the applicant has been
working on the concept for ten years and working intensely for the last three years.
She stated there is funding in place and a plan to work with local businesses as
much as possible. She added that, in regard to the appraisal process, the problem
is that there are few comparable values for street rights of way.
Motion: Mrs. Medlicott moved to waive Council rules for two readings and adopt
Ordinance 2993. Mr. Randels seconded.
Vote: motion carried, 6-7, Butlerin opposition (by abstention).
City Council Business Meeting Page 5 October 20, 2008
NEW BUSINESS
Public Safety Analyst Ken Horvath stated that in order to maintain eligibility for
mitigation project grant funding, the 2004 Jefferson County -City of Port Townsend
Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan must be completed and approved by FEMA by
November 19, 2009. He stated that the City is the only entity to date which has
taken advantage of the program and has received significant grant funding. Since
the City derives so much benefit, he recommends that the City take on the role of
writing the plan (and apply for a grant to fund it). He stated that this presentation is
for information only and on November 17 he will request Council authorization to
submit the grant and to appoint the City Manager as applicant agent for the grant.
In response to a question from Mr. Randels, Mr. Horvath said that the matching
component of the grant would be primarily in-kind matching, which will come from
time spent by all agencies on the project.
PRESIDING OFFICER'S REPORT
Mayor Sandoval stated there will be a meeting about the ferry system tomorrow at
the Pope Marine Building.
Mayor Sandoval asked for volunteers for the City Manager evaluation committee.
Council members Medlicott and Butler will join her on the committee.
CITY MANAGER'S REPORT
City Manager David Timmons reported on the following:
Matt Tyler of Jefferson County has asked for participants to join a committee to work
on updating the County Parks, Recreation and Open Space Plan. Councilors King
and Welch expressed interest in serving, possibly sharing a spot on the committee.
Mr. Timmons and Superintendent Opstad have reached an agreement which will
allow the pool to remain open for the rest of 2008 with the assistance of some of the
stakeholders. This will give the entities time to deal with the longer term issues.
The city audit is nearly complete and an exit interview will be scheduled soon.
EXECUTIVE SESSION
Mayor Sandoval announced that the Council would go into executive session at 8:40
p.m. She stated the session would take approximately ten minutes and no action
would be taken after the session.
RECONVENE
City Council Business Meeting Page 6 October 20, 2008
The meeting was reconvened at 8:52 p.m.
ADJOURN
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 8:53 p.m.
Attest: /''
Pam Kolacy, MMC U
City Clerk
City Council Business Meeting Page 7 October 20, 2008