HomeMy WebLinkAbout070720 packetHISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMITTEE SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES
Date: March 3, 2020 Time: 3:00 pm Location: City Hall Conference Rm. #3
Members Present: Richard Berg (Chair), George Randels, Kathleen Croston, Kathleen Knoblock
Members Absent: Craig Britton (Vice Chair), Cate Comerford (both excused absences) Staff Present: Senior Planner John McDonagh
Topic Motions/Recommendation/ Action
Approval of Minutes Minutes for the Feb. 4, 2020 Regular meeting were approved (3 in favor; 1 abstained)
Approval of the Agenda The May 5, 2020 meeting Agenda was approved unanimously (4-0).
Correspondence/ Attachments: None.
Appearance of Fairness: Chair Richard Berg recused himself from the HPC discussion of DEM 20-003 as he is an agent
for the owner. As Vice Chair Craig Britton was absent, the other 2 sitting members approved
George Randels to act as Chair pro-tern for this item.
Public Comment (for any non-Agenda items): No public comment was offered for any non-Agenda item.
New Business:
A.HPC19-033, Manresa Castle -651 Cleveland HPC asked the applicant to explore use of windows that have the appearance of a
St. Window replacement and "after-the-double-hung assembly but with an upper half that opens as an awning style.
fact" review of exterior light fixture.
No discussion was given to the "after-the-fact" exterior light installation.
An HPC recommendation on both items was deferred until additional info on the
preferred window style could be researched.
Old Business None.
Other Business:
A.DEM20-003, 1715 Gise St. -demolition of 1715 Gise St. lies outside of the National Landmark Historic District (NHLD) and had
brick chimney on a 1928 residence not been inventoried (i.e. scored) to determine whether it qualifies as historic.
B.HPClS-009, Jefferson St. sidewalk-Haller No Action by HPC requested or required. Staff reported on the design change to the
Fountain top steps and sidewalk options.sidewalk issues at the top of Haller Fountain stairs. As part of removing & replacing
Topic Motions/Recommendation/ Action
several of the newly installed (but non-compliant with ADA) concrete panels, space on
both sides of the stairs (each approx. 4' x 4' in size) would be left open for landscaping.
This will aid in achieving ADA compliance with the top of stair landing.
Announcements: HPC member Randels reported to the group on the Main Street Fa�ade improvement program
grant awards and on Main Street discussion on repurposing of the downtown Wayfinding
signage.
Staff reported on a meeting held with the Port of PT, the Washington Trust and other
community stakeholders on Pt. Hudson projects (i.e. breakwater replacement and historic
property assessment).
Next Scheduled Meeting: April 7, 2020.
Adjourn: The meeting was adjoJrned at 5 p.m.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMITTEE SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES
Date: May 5, 2020 Time: 3:00 pm Location: City Hall Conference Rm. #3
Members Present: Richard Berg {Chair), Craig Britton (Vice-chair) George Randels, Cate Comerford, Kathleen Croston, Kathleen Knoblock (arrived after meeting
had started)
Members Absent: Staff Present: Senior Planner John McDonagh
Topic Motions/Recommendation/ Action
Approval of Minutes Minutes for the March 2, 2020 Regular meeting were deferred
Approval of the Agenda The May 5, 2020 meeting Agenda was approved unanimously {5-0).
Correspondence/ Attachments: None.
Appearance of Fairness: Chair Richard Berg disclosed that he is neighbor to the application being reviewed at this
meeting {HPC20-006); however, he has no financial (or other) interest in the project aside from
his position on the committee. The applicant had no objection to Chair Berg participating in
the review.
Public Comment (for any non-Agenda items) No public comment was offered for any non-Agenda item.
Other Business None.
New Business
A.HPC20-006, Dale & Paulette Dell'Ario-740 HPC recommended unanimous approval (6-0) of the Type II setback departure
Taylor St. -Type II Historic Residential including a requirement that a "belt band" be installed to delineate the former
Setback Departure.grade line. No specific HPC recommendation was made concerning an appropriate
treatment for portions of the new concrete foundation wall that will be exposed
above grade.
Announcements: None.
Next Scheduled Meeting: June 2, 2020.
Adjourn: The meeting was adjourned at 4:15 p.m.
citrarPort�1Townsenu
250 Madison Street, Suite 3 I Port Townsend, WA 98368 I 360.379.5095 I www.cityofpt.us
DEVELOPMENT
SERVICES HISTORIC DESIGN REVIEW Of Proposal(s) Within the National Historic Landmark District
APPLICATION#: HPC 1-n -&1.(J
Applicant Name: KP5 LLC (Kathleen Patterson)
Mailing Address: 3010 77th Ave. SE, Suite 105, Mercer Island, WA 98040
Day Phone: 425-454-6789
Architect/Designer/Representative: Broderick Architects (Sean Hill)Mailing Address: 55 South Atlantic Street, Suite 301, Seattle, WA 98134
Day Phone: 206-682-7525
Project Street Address: 129 Taylor StreetLegal Description: Port Townsend O.T. BLK 9, Lots1 to 3 (All), 4 (E47') TL Dist. 50
Parcel Number: 989700901
Prooertv Owu_er Name (if different from Applicant):
Dav Phone:
Project Description:
The existing building is failing and needs to be demolished for safety. A new building is
proposed to be constructed in the existing footprint and would provide new commercial space
on the ground floor with the remaining space dedicated to 18 residential units of which
approximately 14 units would be for low-income hous,··.g.
All applicants and property owners must sign the application below to signify agreement with the proposed application.
The Applicant(s) hereby certifies that all of the above statements and information contained in any
exhibits, plot plans, or other transmittals made herewith are true and provide an accurate presentation of the proposed project. The applicant( s) acknowledges that any action taken by the City of Port Townsend based in whole or in part on this application may be reversed if it develops that any such statement or
other information contained herein is false.
The undersigned hereby saves and holds the City of Port Townsend harmless from any and all causes of action,judgments, claims, or demands, or from any liability of any nature arising from any
noncompliance with any restrictive covenants, plat restrictions, deed restrictions, or other restrictions
which may have been established by parties other than the City of Port Townsend.
06/29/2020
Applicant
Property Owner (if different from applicant) J?Me 3 0 2020
CITY OF P".'\RT TO'NMS�ND
05.15 Page 1 of 2
/
✓-
/
/
. /. /
/
/ / / ,, ,, ,.,.--
LOT8
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
/
/
/ / /
l •
. / \'
\
.
/
,,-✓ ,, ,,
\
_,,,, /
\
\
\
/
\ \
\
' '
'� . ,-ti. �
/
'� t .,
\'a'�
\
\ ,.. _ _,, !e1,_opk9!
.;.,,,,,,..,,"' \ \
LOT7
\
\
\
.,,.
/
/ -
\
\
\
\
,
\
\
,/
\ \
,,,,�-\
\ \
\
\
\
\
\ \ \ \ \ \
\ Jf't,
'"" \
\
\
\
� .'l,,
/
"
llfACttAAE1'
LOT 3
✓-,,.--✓-/ ,,
,,,--
✓ / / ,, /
/
/ ,,
,, / ,, / / / / / / ,,
.,,,,.,,,.·,,,,.
/ ,,
,/
./. ,.,,,,,, ' ,, \
✓-,,
\
\
LOT8
,,,-
\
TAX PARCEL 989700808
/ ,,. _,,,,,,, \
\
\
\
\
\
\LOT6
\
\
\
/ ; . /
�✓-\
\
\
' \
\ LOT7
' '/
/
/
\
\
-✓---� :/
\' EXIS!ING DECK
--
/
\ \ \
.0
'l,,
\ _,,-
/ .. ,,,,.-\ . '
/
/
\ \
\ \. ,,.-,
\
\
\
\ •/ , .. / \
\ \ \ \
\
\
\
\
\
\.
.\ •✓ ' / \
\
\
\
LOT5 \
\
\
\
\
/ \ /
\ /
/
/
/
/
/
/, /
/
/
/
/
\ ' ' \ ' \
\ \ \ \ \ \
\ \
:::CEL INFORMATION
129 TAYLOR STRc PORTTOV,,.,SEN:>�A 99368 OWNER: KPSLLC ::im��it�NE #n:l ,WA 98110
PARCEL NUMBER: CONTACT: KATI-lLEEN PETERSON 989700901 p,atteJSon_kalhteen@holmail com
LEGAL DESCRIPTION: PORTTOWNSENJ OT. BLK 9, LOTS 1 TO 3
PLANNING NOTES
JURISDICTION: ZONING: ZONING OVERLAY: SHORELM:S: LOT AREA:
HEIGHT: PARKING:
PORT TOWNSEND C-111 HISTORIC COMMERC 50'
IA!., PTUGA SPECtAI.. HI OVERLAY HISTORIC WATERFRONT 23.JJJ SF (0 34 AC I
50 FT (45 FT PROPOSED) NO ON-SITE PARKING (NO CHANGE)
JUN 3 0 2020
,-., I TOWMSCND CITY OF pom• r,
(ALL).4 (E471 ll D�T. 50
�SITE
V) r-z UJ
� (.!)
� z0 0::: _J <( => a.. Ci!
<( I-z >-:E u
.....J <( _J <( 0..
0::: 0:::: -
� 0 <(
CJ) r u LJ.J -
u Cl! <(
� u -Cl! LJ.J D 0 Cl! co
CX)
CX) 0)
<( �6 z LU U) z � 0 I-I-0:::: 0 • I-LU LU 0:::: I-U)
0_J
<(
0)
r-
Ll'l N Ll'l "
N "° 0
0 ,.,,
N
'"" '<t UJ ,.,, I-,- c:o
� er,
I-' z
UJ 0UJ I� \.Jtn z UI
j::: � �� -l -�� . f-Vl � Ll'l UJ Ll'l Vl
SITE PLAN
1
HISTORICAi nlST
==o
[
',
r
|1 l,
ii
-
-'
-1
1
-
,
.
-\
.
1
-
-
-'
@-
il
F =
U m =o r-=z t-z t o o C z U 'T
t o o
./.
'
.
'
/"
ii
g =o E !tr o s ==F f;
=B6 E
E e J
,i tl li
;-.
i t.l Ll
--
:-
-
-
;
:
--
i
:
:
:
: -
::
-
-
r
,
-
;
!l
1
r
lr
l
l
li
'
r
ir
l
l
,,
l,il li
l_
!
-
.t
i'
-_
-
n
li IJ ri *!
m z U ii z -o z o
fl
,
q
11
i-
-
1
l_
.
.
i
.l
Af
r
ir
sp
{r
ii
lli
i
ti
ii
'r
'
-
"
1
i
-
_
:!
:
'
ti
it
jl
i
l
*_
-
4
r
_
_
t
-
i
"
_
-
-
i i
.]
_
!I ll i I _l
T
::
rr
AD
M
I
R
A
L
T
Y
AP
A
R
T
M
E
N
T
S
RE
P
L
A
C
E
M
E
N
T
BU
I
L
D
I
N
G
12
9
TA
Y
L
O
R
ST
R
E
E
T
o
PO
R
T
TO
W
N
S
E
N
D
,
WA
98
3
6
8
;;I
BR
O
D
E
R
I
C
K
AR
C
H
I
T
E
C
T
S
55
S.
AT
L
A
N
T
I
C
ST
R
E
E
I
SU
I
T
E
#3
0
1
SE
A
T
T
L
E
,
WA
S
H
I
N
G
T
O
N
98
1
34
20
6
.
6
8
2
.
7
5
2
5
-6 o fr 6 q
NJ
n ON
F=zq
ti
/
O
Jq it
r zE
-lE
i-
r
'
1
'
1
i
,l
!
ii
i
i
'
.f
i
--
-
'
-
-
"
"
i
l
:#
-L
F
;l
i
'I I 'I :l J 't 'I 'I I :!'I
-l
g
:i 'I .t 'I :i ji ,I i .l ;l 't :l I
U rn o t-=o z z I NJ z I T1
t-v C]
.-
r
1
t-o o n 2
o-I a
-l
E
-lE El=
1
:t
'
-
T
-
-
:
:
_-
_
;
'
ii
l
l
'i
".
rll
ii ii |.il
,iL
^i
l-
il
n
l
a
ii
r|
=
Hs
l=
EE
,1
3
,i
-
-
r
.
-
:
:
:
:
-
:
I
ii
l,
:'
l i i
AD
M
I
R
A
L
T
Y
AP
A
R
T
M
E
N
T
S
RE
P
L
A
C
E
M
E
N
T
BU
I
L
D
I
N
G
12
9
TA
Y
L
O
R
ST
R
E
E
T
o
PO
R
T
TO
W
N
S
E
N
D
,
WA
98
3
6
8
tt
'
BR
O
D
E
R
I
C
K
AR
C
H
I
T
E
C
T
S
55
S.
AT
L
A
N
T
I
C
S
T
R
E
E
I
,
SU
I
T
E
#
3
0
1
SE
A
T
T
L
E
,
WA
S
H
I
N
G
T
O
N
98
1
3
4
20
6
.
6
8
2
.
7
5
2
5
I I o 4.o s J
Ll
J
i
z
5>os nb H!
Es
E €8
EE
slF clp
+
BI
E
4t
2
FI
E
+a e
Jg El
q
e
=a
I
+fi
PU
G
T
I
SO
U
f
f
D
x t,a t
t P
==a g 6 e
l .T
t
t-o o F z I o v o C z U 'T
l o o F
"r
A
r
,
Es o9 EB qtE
fr
t
1
xtE
I
a :"
1
=
{l
:
xt
t
t
+a 6N I ,E
A 4._3t=
-,
-
,E
il
li
.,
J
-
f;
g
H
alE
x t,=
91
4
rl
9
tl
a
l*Elt
ql5 gg t<
+P\r
EX
|
S
I
Co
N
C
.
WA
|
-
K
o I==E'm 6 c)fr !=o z
@ m o n o
o@moFT-v
N @ m o G T -a N
b +c s o N
z o C z =(a
m x at
,{z,
_G
)==m v v,r{@ g r I z o
=m _€{r o v at i.
l
t!s r I z,o
.T
I
t-o o 't
r
t-z I N)z U T1 o o 7
-I
OH
W
M
-
6 o
5 !t
;
E
:\l
z &l
i
!t
i E
I et
3
xt
d
e
+q i AE Its
xtd
4E
I Etc
fil
=Xl;
3
x
t 5ls
I
BIJ el€
o o o
]=Et
a
!
si
l
-
ff
i d-
RO
O
F
CN
O
P
Y
-:.
i
W
-
o
I
AD
M
I
R
A
L
T
Y
AP
A
R
T
M
E
N
T
S
RE
P
L
A
C
E
M
E
N
T
BU
I
L
D
I
N
G
12
9
TA
Y
L
O
R
ST
R
E
E
T
.
PO
R
T
TO
W
N
S
E
N
D
,
WA
98
3
6
8
tt ;
BR
O
D
E
R
I
C
K
AR
C
H
I
T
E
C
T
S
55
S.
AT
L
A
N
T
I
C
ST
R
E
E
I
,
SU
I
T
E
#3
0
1
SE
A
T
T
L
E
,
WA
S
H
I
N
G
T
O
N
98
1
3
4
20
6
.
6
8
2
.
7
5
2
5
I f o 4.o o J
5
o
P=xz E:
6z
o
4e
ff
i w 5
i 'T
t
f-o o n t-z I (,F U -T
1
t-o o N
oh
q
4
1t
z
!i
l
i
Elg a
qls Elr
!
tc
9lE It le
;!t
5 glc
61
5
Y,
6 El=t
+N s 3 5 te
6lr
!
AB It la
x =
Ete
jl-El:
r
H
elF qlP
ls
tl
l
I ll
s gE !g 1E EE
I
:lg qE
..
,
n
n 11
E EE xt6
I
.T
t
t-o o F t-z I 5 -l
:E T1 t-o F
E il a
AH
W
L
I
x
AD
M
I
R
A
L
T
Y
AP
A
R
T
M
E
N
T
S
RE
P
L
A
C
E
M
E
N
T
BU
I
L
D
I
N
G
12
9
TA
Y
L
O
R
ST
R
E
E
T
.
PO
R
T
TO
W
N
S
E
N
D
,
WA
98
3
6
8
t;;
BR
O
D
E
R
I
C
K
AR
C
H
I
T
E
C
T
S
55
S.
AT
L
A
N
T
I
C
ST
R
E
E
I
SU
I
T
E
#3
0
1
SE
A
T
T
L
E
,
WA
S
H
I
N
G
T
O
N
98
1
34
20
6
.
6
8
2
.
7
5
2
5
I o 4.o g @ J
(r
l
5H oq
FF
-t
->i zL v)
BLUEACCENT
SHEET METAL PILASTER,
BLUE ACCENT
PAMPET W BROWN
SHEET METAL COPING
BLUEACCENT BAND
FIBER BAND
TERRACOTTA (PRIMARY
SIMILARTO EXISI
BLDG BRICK COLOR
PROPOSED 4 STORY
CONSTRUCTION
COURTYARD (SOUTHWEST) - CONCEPTUAL ELEVATION
BUILT UP CEMENT
FIBER BAND W
BROWN SHEET
METAL FLASHING
TERMCOTTA
ACCENT, TYP
FIBERGLASS
WINDOW
BROWN
CANOPY BROWN W
BLUEACCENT BAND
6+31r2"'4fl FLOOR
{ffiddil NEWDEcK
+12r1f.2ND FLOORLIGHT SCONCE
NEW DECK @
WATERFRONT
PAGET SOUND
:\/32'= 1'-O',
-
CONCEPTUAL VIEW FROM TAYLOR STR
PART OF BUILDING TO REMAIN,
l+rnonoseo 4 STORY
m _ffi
*N
T _F--i-lNlE-:t--
:
ltIl
-::::l-
T TAYLOR STREET
=
PUGET SOUND
WATERFRONT (SOUTH EAST) - CO N CEPTUAL ELEVATION TAYLOR STREET (NORTHEAST) - CONCEPTUAL ELEVATION
ilil trdsil ilil
A
T
e
H
hf &tflil 'A ZLA ZAI
T ilT
PA! tlLsrilil I TA\ ZL\; ilil
ZN TA\ Nilil I
1 ra raa; :il
LOOKING SOUTH
^I '^ A! Z/NIz!z/N nII I
7/A 7/5TI 'TAII n z\ 7/NI tr
PROPOSED 4 STORY PART OF BUILDING TO REMAIN
j ::ir_e rl ,rr:il I rl :l ,!,i *-lr ,1, -i=':
l!..C I rt i :
i T-;,-l-li,.r, i
-r-* - -:
'j
It:i,.-.,.- - _-:
--1
i WATE
RST
@(0
cY.)(n3F<z=LtJ oEszfrl- z ,J)'E==
SEE<35>_E:FV FIi uJ
3H;
=q?=O)
:
(t) .nL-ill.\\J rxLUql\ol-RIU-
tFrv d-U r-5
-
l!FM. *2t! U=o r3c;arg aEll
CONCEPTUAT
EXTERlORS
HISTORICAL DISI
63/32" = 1'-0'L- i 3132'= 1'.o"03:
*.
,
]
.
.
.
i
d
r
.
i,
n
'
-"
.
:
,
n
f
i
:1
.
"
{
:
6
.
:
-;
|
:
i
d
&r
q
{
,i.
i
i1
Th
,
'$
{j I I z l t
t
{h
s
r
1
-i
Lll
l
o o z o rn +C t-rT
I {'T
t F _J t-o n 0 -l m rr
l
-J f-o x z o (t
)o C -l I =rn
(.
n -t
u f;
o z o rT
I
-l C t-s m €'T
1 n =m 'T
t v o z rr o o 2 o z o n I
tl
i
.
,
r
;
.
$
\*
f
*
r.
'
l
r
r
y
f
l
$
Fi
;
i
i
t,
tt
m
E
WN
II
6-
il
l
0q
ti
l
li U u H'n il I
b:*_it
,
.,
1:
&q6i
a
l
's
l
l
::
l
!n
l
)
t
I
.l !I
l
1
qf
!I
-t
$r
t
n
l
l
l
flEm
l
tl6f
;
t
l
-:
r
q
l
l
t-
n
.
l
€l
r8
ri TI
II
*'
l
.J
t
'
ru
t
-t
J
'
ff
i
'
c
'
EH
N
A
@a
il
l llmt
ff
i
l
-7
/
,
"J
J
rt
l
r
tt II
+a nl
il
l
&t
Jt
u
tn rn
l
rl t-
l
]q
m
r
y
[
F
!
:@
!
F
}r
y
*
E]
"
*
*
,5
f
f
i
n
.r
y
.
f
f
j*
n
m ra
l rl
ff
i
q
l-
F Il
t
t
AD
M
I
R
A
L
T
Y
AP
A
R
T
M
E
N
T
S
RE
P
L
A
C
E
M
E
N
T
BU
I
L
D
I
N
G
12
9
TA
Y
L
O
R
ST
R
E
E
T
.
PO
R
T
TO
W
N
S
E
N
D
,
WA
98
3
6
8
JJ
'
BR
O
D
E
R
I
C
K
AR
C
H
I
T
E
C
T
S
55
S.
AT
L
A
N
T
I
C
ST
R
E
E
I
,
SU
I
T
E
#3
0
1
SE
A
T
T
L
E
,
WA
S
H
I
N
G
T
O
N
98
1
34
20
6
.
6
8
2
.
7
5
2
5
-I o 4.o I
\
z>
Fi
(1
=t
r
oi
v1
>F
John McDonagh
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
CAUTION: Extemal Email
napc-l@googlegroups.com on behalf of director <director@napcommissions.org>
Tuesday, June 30, 2020 9:42 AM
NAPC-L
[NAPC-L] Registration is Now Open! FORUM 2020: Preservation Coast to Coast -at
Home
------... -·------------· . ·---�-:-:. -· ��� �:-=--��::
E
-------·----=====-----
.... ------·••-----• ---�-,.__. __
___ :.:.:.::::=------------.. . .... -.. -..... _. .. ------__ ...., __________ ... --., .. --•-··--------� -----... ---·-·····
• --♦----· -------
-·---,_ ---------··--------�•--::-:::;::_ __ _
-...... ·---··-------·· _.,.,. --··--
·-------� --• - -�-........ w .... �
------__ _.....�---... .. -... ··-----·-----... ----· ... • -"" .. -...... -�......... --·-······-·. �------·-·----.. -·--······-� .. ,., .. , . : :::: ::··............. ·:::.:::::::: .. :.:.:..:....:.. ··::; :�-:;;:
... . .-'... --. ..:...��
CELEBRATING 11
1
Exciting news!
Registration is now open for FORUM 2020: Preservation Coast to Coast~ at Home I
Since we can't all be together in Tacoma this year, please join us online the week of August 3-9, 2020, for an exciting
series of presentations, tours and networking opportunities that will build on the diverse and rich content originally
planned for our in-person event. FORUM 2020: Preservation Coast to Coast~ at Home will feature many of our
longstanding traditions such as the Opening and Closing Plenaries, the Commission Excellence Awards, interactive
educational sessions, roundtables, and as always, a chance to connect with fellow preservationists from across the
country. And since we can't all be there in person, we will bring you a series of thoughtfully curated virtual tours that will
spotlight the rich history and historic resources of Tacoma. As we get closer to FORUM, registrants will receive unique
passcodes to access each and every event.
For more information on registration and event details, please check the event page for
FORUM 2020: Preservation Coast to Coast~ at Home!
We are grateful for the support of our local, state and national partners as we've shifted gears to enhancing our current
content to an educational and exciting online experience.
For assistance, send email to director@napcommissions.org
Additional guidelines and group policies may be found on the NAPC website. http://napcommissions.org/napc-l/
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "NAPC-L" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to napc
l+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/napc-l/2774945e-c4e3-4bb7-bfc4-
9818eeb49773n%40googlegroups.com.
2