HomeMy WebLinkAbout050823 Special Session Financial Sustinability Task Force Joint Meeting with City Council- Added After MeetingOptions for
Financial Sustainability
City Council Work Shop
May 8, 2023
Presentation Objective
This presentation reviews a range of alternatives for reaching
Financial Sustainability and providing desired Level of
Services in the City of Port Townsend. The presentation
covers the following topics:
Background
Financials
Range of Options
Next Steps
PortTownsend
Financial Sustainability Background
roject Purpose:
Engage community members in a conversation around the City's long-term
financial sustainability and its ability to provide quality municipal services.
Build knowledge in the community about how the budget works, the
constraints Port Townsend faces, and how everyone can work together to
prioritize needs.
Part of the "Engage PT" initiative
Taskforce charge:
Advise City staff on community engagement materials and strategies.
Provide a report to City Council with directional recommendations for
ancial sustainability and delivery of quality municipal services,
nsidering both revenue and cost/service options.
City .! %Wi�iN (� li�r� rf' Ap ,1P„Fortl"ownsend
lWWNk 4h
t�
inancial
Picture
Ending Cash Balance
ear Historical Cash Flow
m
m
am
Ending Fund Balance
ioYear Financial Model
ENDING 11= UN I IBA1LA1114C11:::::: & I AII:RGII::.::.:: I
.. ...... ... ... ...
(Geneirall, Streets, & RIDET, Coom yr s# & 1l)eb-t 11::::u nds)
Status Quo
(6 4-3 4-1 4-1 4-j
D CC5 Y 6!1 U LA Ln V� U0 kA Ln
U U U U
4-1 LLJ I
U U 4- rq U U ILL ILL- ILL iz UL UL
<
< rq LO 0) 0
00 0 H 0 rq N rq rq rq rn
0 0 COY a 0 ) N 0 rq N rq rq ro 0 N 0 0 0 0 0 0
N rq rq
rq CN 0 p,J N 0
N rq
iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiillillillillillillilliI ToW Ending Fund Mance —:,TotaPoky Reserves
Level of Service
Level of service discussion
hat does level of service look like in each scenarios?
ow do we achieve each scenario?
What is the impact to our community in each scenario?
Do Nothing
Sustain Current Services
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Enhance Services
Level of service discussion
hat does level of service look like in each scenarios?
ow do we achieve each scenario?
What is the impact to our community in each scenario?
Do Nothing
Sustain Current Services
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Enhance Services
w
hat does
Level of service discussion
of service look like in each scenarios?
achieve each scenario?
hat is the impact to our community in each scenario?
Do Nothing
Sustain Current Services
....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Enhance Services
10
Level of service discussion
Notes from Task Force meeting 3
Do Nothing
• No new revenue
• Service level reductions
• "Fall off a cliff"
• Efficiency here also
• Describe the impacts of
doing nothing
• Impact on major
initiatives (pool)?
• Potential service cuts
No Net Loss
Sustain Current Services
• Raise revenue to sustain
current services
• No new services
• Trade-offs
• "No cliff"
• How to provide same service
at less cost (Lean initiatives)—
how far can this go?
• Look not only at revenue side
• Needed revenue to maintain
Enhance Services
• Efficiency remains
important
• Trade-offs
• New revenue
• Amount needed for
enhanced services
13.
Efficiencies
A few example actions the City has taken in recent times to gain
efficiencies (not all inclusive):
Contracting for pool services
Enhanced volunteer programs for Parks & other areas in the City
Online permitting
Public Experience Liaisons and new City Hall front counter
On Call Services
Change to mowing
Lean thinking
Electronic council and advisory board materials (eliminate paper)
Updated financial software and electronic payment options
(coming soon)
Options for
Financial
Sustainability
Balancing options forfinancial
sustainability
uiir Iii iiia g
S ura tegIii es
ri cfirms e taxes
aiiia d fees)
3 -OW e\i'ds olfServ��ce
(redUJC(1:1�
S
Ffi c II e e s)
If new fuiiiad g s bra tegl���es
are not pursued,
alternatives are for a
community to focus on
g - o v,�/ "t 11 � and/or redl),/ j,c e
14
Proposed criteria for evaluating
revenue options
Magnitude: How much net revenue could this option generate?
Growth: How is this revenue source expected to grow or decline in
the future?
Stability: How stable is this revenue source?
Equity: How much does the revenue option align the burden of who
pays with who benefits?
Political feasibility: How politically feasible is the option?
Restrictions/Alignment with needs: What can the revenue be used
for? Can it meet the City's needs?
�5
General Purpose
Tax Revenue Options
with Preliminary Scoring
Property tax
increase
Could fund nor -nett loss
$ 50,1$1 000, —
Subject to I'?%
I�nnpactts all property
Requires voter
Can be used for
- ttennporary,,
rlr enln�a ncel'nne nentts
��,���
�u�d,getta r'y growthYlwn
Can be r,:.ngni�ng
e r
app,rl;:i'W'al
anyp4Jrp,G:Dse
3
per'nnanentt or
I'i�rnniitted ,ur ,r:yse
Current 22"°% rate
Water,, Sewer &
efff to I 2/20,23i
Can 6,e
Sttorrnnwwatter
Cr,uld fund nc:r-nett loss
I X� increase _
Would grow as
Jan 20,24 reverts, to
Impacts, all utility
irnrplern7,enttecl
Can be used for
'��
Utilitytax
or enhancernnenentts
�'"n;�UC���P
dewelr�pinnenttgrrra
2f��'����I2k
users,
�itt#n-muttvr::ctter
any
2
increases
reducttir.,rn in
apprcival
revenue
Electric
Coulddloss
funer
could grow as
Irnnpactts all utility
Requires, �voter
Can be used �ffe::or
2.5625
e lnr ne
7�nern
�Ongoing
�v'eln Innentt grows
users
approval
any purpose
"� o,uld grow°w�ittln
'Tax
"�„grow
Current ratter 0.2%,I
Impacts,Impacts,all business,
Already
Can be used ' for
&O
CO'Uld fund no -nett loss
increased ecannnnicOngoing-
rnna�x'innua�nn allowedrrwners.
developnnentt
ittwnplernnentted
any purpose
Allows, ws itrnnplernnenttattio,n
of a parking
Irnnpaclts ttc:vursirnt.
nnanagenn,entt prrngrarnn
WouldNeeds,
Would grow with ttimrne
Concern over
study,
beI�'e:
Can e used for
Parking fees
(assume 50,10, our off
312,5 �u
Self-sustainingcoininnWnitty
buy -in,
1,0100 sttall& at 50(''
and infflattc�rn
accessibilitty and
and council decis,i+:)n
any
airy pure -arse
upper sttc,-ry housing
occupancy at 5 per
da
Fees rniustt beattttrib,utted
Can be
Irn7;pae�s specific
User Fees,
directly to a provider's
TBE),
Wc,uld grow with use
Ongoing
users
irnnplernneantted
3.125
General Purpose
Non -Tax Options
Preliminary Scoring
General Purpose
I 0,G3�P �ff� of Leased space
Current leased spaces.
Charge lease CO3uld reduce the ability
at $15/yearI�I�II�I, est. _
dl! nes pay rentt ffor
rates fl ,r"City to, rl: vide subsidized
p
1500,0 per year..
N/A
Stable
p-ublic bf''ne�ffitt. The Citty
Council decls'Ir:Yn
Currentt subsidy
3,.0,0333333
Space at Mttn_ services for pubkc
�SF las estturnnratted sand
'
subsldl'zes services like
suppK.jrtts c(.:),nununiy
View/City Hall benefit
the food bank*
be ttere
named rverified)
fnl-ttr::YrlCal society.
Addresses reduction of
Inn,prr.lyes sustainability.
In'cr'ease reserve
ser'v'ices and .-a'y'es, on
Recessions, are prime ttinnie-
Equitable to, ennpl'r.Yyees
Sustainable
fund balance Sttabllll'zes,'Cltty service.-
unexpected infrastructure
Iinw'e'sttd'nnentt p(,:),oI
for government to build
and proy'Ides better '
Council decision
Services and
4.1 66,66, 67
re' uIr3n1enttS.
c4stt-Helps city weather
In'frasttructture instead of
services,
Coninunitty
reeem,ions.,
laying eo le rYf'f.,
IRe in..-ttatte Fleet Creattes crinslsttentt
Saves one tti nne
Allows, g+lc,d year
unexpected expenses
funding to be applied
Sustainable
Replaeelnn�ntt funding ffr:Yrc replacenn,entt
when e€iulpnn,entt fails,
r
N/A
High sustainability
conniniunitty projects
'bervices and
4.16666667
Reserves, with one of vehicles a.11r--w-
Also save-
Ennal,nttenance
strategy
strategy
instead of fleet
Coinnaniu'nitty
trlr'ml�e ffurrds trre'araslttlaa�a7 to, eletrrPc'fleetr_
,costs for r7ld vehicles
rep,laceRlientt
Saves, one $Ilene
Establish a Cr'ecite s con s,i5tentt
unexpected expenses
Allows, g4:Yetid yearFac
funding ffo,r nlalnttenace
when building systems ,yste,
funding to be applied
Sustainable
F::� ul urn gs such as, rcF.�+:Y'
al s_ Also, saves
Hugh sustainability
lhry cr,am�rnrounitt rcr-�e clic
�+ projects,
l:aunef eclsa�r:an
Services and
��L� �rt��d�t�d��i7
IReseirlvie with one
re Iaclm,ents, car' pet,
p p
unitre nded dalnic e ttt:Y
g
,�,
strategy
instead +::lf bWlldl,r, g
Coininru,nitty
ttlllYn'.e funds,
painting, etc.
buildings, by staying
repair's
ahead r.. -if rep-air,s.,
1 1%
%6k 66,
17
eneral Purpose Non -Tax Options cont.
with Preliminary Scorin
Gantract IPark Absent,crecting a imietrr:j Savings c:),uld result in no,
Services, - parks, district, could increase in olpercitio,nal
J e ff e r son Co. create efficiency of costs. Assurne $1 in, per
servi-ce. year continues.
N/A
Sustainable for the City
finances. May not be
sustainable for parks.
Maintains, access for
everyone. G.xncern
over the ability to build
new parks, as the city
grows.
Council and Cc.),unty
decision
May help with park
inainteriance
deficiencies. Could
expand
recreatio,nal
prograrns with
ilpffi-.mrm Cn,
2 8333333 11
Nr.. -i savings to general
fund because internal
ILoss cif local control and
service fund. Could be
Operational and
Cantract
tailored services for
nic:),re efficient,, but nmy
mijay not be
Engineering
urban needs (ie., non-
case local cc..j,ntr(..jl and
No, guarantee of staffing
Concern raver lack of
Council and County
strate,gic. May have
ni,c-iforized). Still requires
public prc),cess as's,ociated
N/A
attention for city
2.33333333
services , -
given labor inarket
decisir.in
imisalignini�ent
Jeffers(.:),n &:).
anagel"TTent.
11'between
with key features like non-
specific p,robleinjs
urban and
IRedu,cti(,j,n in public
ni�r.:Acmized transipc),rtation.
rural go,als.
process.
Also would require
cc),ritract nianager(s)
Saves Overhead.
Lass of local control and
Savings undetermined.
0p,eratir.mal and
tailored services for
Not likely a cost saying
may not be
G.-mtract Planning
urban needs, (ie., non-
C(..-j,n,cern over lack of
Services, -
nicato,azed). Still requires,
unless, prograins, like
N/A
No, guarantee of staffing
attention for city
Council and County
strate,gic. May have
2.,33 i33333
Jefferson Co..
inianagern,ent.
histaric p,reservatiran are
given labor niarket
slpedfic pr(Dbleiria
deci5ir,:),n
inisalighni�ent
e1iininated.
between urban and
Reductio,ri in p,ul6kc
Saves, overhead
rural go,als.
Savings undeteriniined.
Olperational and
Co,ntrcict IPreIICe
IRequires, analysi[s. Saves
Co-ncern over lack of
rn,ay not be
Serykes -
IRural versus, urban
overhead, equip,nient, and
N/A
N(::), guarantee of staffing
attention for city
Council and County
strate,gic. May have
1.91666667
1policing
given labrar niarket
decisir.m
niiscilighni�ent
Jefferscan Cc).
other potential
siqedfic problenis
efficiencies.
between urban and
rural aracils.
No, savings deterl"nined-
Current Structure
Delarnarter rep,(..-j,rt,,
Would result in a
�CILEO Coop,erati've
revenue /exp,e nse gap, of
considered the
est. $40,0k; 4 annually
Libraries, of Eastern
Contract ILibrary
annexation of PT
Sustainable for the City
Olyrnpics) aligns the
Services -
Library
based on taxing auth(::),rity.
,may n.jt be
finances. Mr.
M aintains access for
Co,uncil and
needs cif City and
Currently, no general
N/A
Jefferc(.:),n County
3.16666667
Jefferson County
to Jefferson Gaunty
fund subsidy of the
sustainable fr,:)r library
everycme.
Library decisif:m
County by w(.:)rking
Library
Library
library. In the future, ni,ay
services-
,a
together to nike
(Noveni,ber 20,01)
seenilem services
require general fund
for cc.),rniniunity
cr.:mtributio,ri due to
inflaticm.
Gantract IPark Absent,crecting a imietrr:j Savings c:),uld result in no,
Services, - parks, district, could increase in olpercitio,nal
J e ff e r son Co. create efficiency of costs. Assurne $1 in, per
servi-ce. year continues.
N/A
Sustainable for the City
finances. May not be
sustainable for parks.
Maintains, access for
everyone. G.xncern
over the ability to build
new parks, as the city
grows.
Council and Cc.),unty
decision
May help with park
inainteriance
deficiencies. Could
expand
recreatio,nal
prograrns with
ilpffi-.mrm Cn,
2 8333333 11
'TransportationRoads:, 'Trafls
Transportation, Roads, Trails
Tax Revenue Options
with Preliminary Scoring
Transp„rttatti-ekn
ould grow with
Salestax available
P enefitt C�isttr'i'ctt
Cr}ul°e� fund raa::�--nett Lr;��s�s
021?lo = 550,000,
.
crease r-rn
increased ecnnnic
for 10 years with
1111pactts all
d'!
�May require voter
�ansr'tta#i�c.)n
Fr::vr ttrpY,:v
3.25
sales tax
or enhancrnnenentts
clevelc.)p'nnentt
a
rode in'itte nunn�ber'
purchases
approval
l�
prjeclPs
of renewals
TranspYnrttatti�r:kn
''�r"'Y)ulc� gregrowwithitth
tax available
Can be
P,enel�itt C�isttrictt
Youun racy -nett n-��,
�, —
g1.1 e� — 27 5,000,
Incr'easecl ecl.nna.}In7ac
year;males:
r:�r I yearswith
are�pac#s a
In�mp lenientted
Foar ttrans� uvr::ttattir.::vn
p' '
.37
sales� taxclev'eh::rprnnentt
yr enhancnnenentts
indefinite nulnb-er'
p urchase&
without voter '
pro eclrs
r}f renewals
approval
SalesTramtax available
fan be
�enefitt Cl s#Ire
i�cli
Y�ul� mune! no, -net lass
"21�fee — $186,00,0,
',�G��I�I
Wouldgra;::rv�* with rn�c)re
for 10 ears with
"�'ar>mue fee for all
Iln� len�enttee!
For trans Y::vrtt
3.0625
or enhancanle,nentts
vehicles registered
indefinite nunnber'
vehicle owners,owners,wItthcwtt
voter '
projects.
vehicle license fee
of renewals
approval
5,GO k/hous,ing unit
ru:pvvtth ccwlcl be
x 50, units, per year =
reduced by attainable
250,00,011 per year
housing incentive
Can be
Fc),rr,Capital prr,::rjecli'
la'npactt Fees strategy to
current levels of
prrn,graln7 for additticnal
Ong, -rung until
II'nnpactt Fees
In,pactts, specific
III'nnpleannentteei
specific to the fee
achieve atttarnable
develoin7entt. $5,00D
units. If all newunitts
sttrattegy is
4.2,E
-� Trarrspe:rr'ttatti�Nrr
users,
witthevutt'votter
(InY,usllrl,g, streets,
housing genal_
wo,ulel need to, be
are a'niarkett rate (75 per
aehi-eveel_
approval
parks)
justified by study for
year), then gr'c:jwtth in
non Inllttr:Yr`I:Zreel
revenue - goes, up.. to,
..
Cc,,uld fund n(::, --net loss Based on ' CapitalIlnlproves, an.and-Ilrnnpactts s
all property Require'votter' For capital projects
Capital IBS:}ncl One #ia'nne In7rrney Inainttains 2.625
or en�haancrn7le,nerrtts, InnprYnvea'nnentt IF+lan c.i°w�ners apprr,:xval specific to,the bun,ncl
Infrasttructture
Parks, Pools, Public Facilities
Tax Options
with Preliminary Scoring
:
:.. �,� .
.......
Parks,
Po I ,
u bliic Facilities
Metropolitan IPark
Cr,,uld fund no, -nett loss,
$0,75 per $1,000, _
Subject to, I %
Impacts all pro,pertty
Requires �voter
District
or ernhn�rncer'nnenentts,
—$11,600,10,00,
budgetary growth+zw�ners
Ongwain,g
approvalappY'w'aI
For park pra�eclhs.
3.5625
property tax
Parks and
Crwld fund no, -net la::�•s
Subjectt(.:) 11%Innp-a�ctts
all pro,pertty
Re€iuires �voter �
For parks services,,,
year I vy
Ludgettary grrrwrtth�
F'ir'niitted to, 6, years
3.125
Recrreatticin District
or ernln�rneer'nnenentts,
lirnnitted
owners,
owners,�rs�
approval
approvala
Ila'nnttad tterrrnn
to, ?fir years,
Parks and
Cr'Puld (Fund no -net h:rss
Subject ttri I D/a
Ilanp actts all pr+:aperrtt�°
IReciuires wc:�tterr�
For parks services,
Recreatti(,,ns
year levy
Ludgettary grrwwtthj
F'ir'nniitted to, 6, years
3..h 5
or enh7arrcer'n�enentts�
(zwrners
approval
lirnitted tterni
Service ,area
lirnnitted to, 6 years
Public Facilities
Cr1,uld fund n-r._,nett loss
Wr.:)uld grow with
Ilnnpactts, all
Re€iulres voter
For a regional
District�'-�2o
_ 55g,�1^�"g'
increased ecr�n�-,rnnii�c
C�ngc:jing
.0u625
or enhnan�cenienentts
purchases
approval
facility
sales tax
dewe6oa'nnentt
$5,10,0 /hous,ing unit
Growth could be
x 50, urn'itts, per year =
reduced by attainable
250M000 per year
housing incentive
Can be
For capital prrn,lectts,
Impact(,
I'nn pa�gttr4
��r,
{g�lrrIlal
�g gu, �ttil
lannpactts Specific
in'nplennentted
specific tto the fee
Parks Open
aceve attainable
dev�l"nlentt5,000
Wnittslff allnew units,
strategy
3.5625
Space
n(rusirng goal.
�p
would need to be
are narkett rate (75 per
achieved.
users
vitthrutt voter
�
(hrusing, sttrees,
apprr:7-val
parks)
justified by study for
year), then growth in
nctn Innt:. tto,rized
revenue goes, up to
facilities
37510,00.,
,Current fees, V0F0uk
Can be
Fees�njustbeattributed
'Current cost to,run
linpacttspecific
ii'npleni,e,n'tted
Speci'ffic'ffnrO&M,
Poo] Use fees
r
existing po,o, $600k
W(.::ruld gr4::wwith use
.
Ongrr:�Ing
.6, 75
directly
se
Yltth"Wtt voter
of facility
Increase fees, 1 ON
approval
V.
Housing
Tax Revenue Options
Preliminary Scoring
Developnnent
Services, Fees,
Provide higher level of
res,p,(.:.m&[veness, for
perniff processing by
funding staff positions.
Fees niust be attributed
directly to, a providers,
1131C
W(.:),uld grow as,
deyelc:.,piv�ent grows,
Ong(,:)ing
linjpacts, specific
users,
,Can be
iivjpleni�ented
witho,ut voter
approval
'Suppe .:.jrt& crifical
attainable housing
needs
liniplerniented of County
Provides,
Aff or do ble
level~ ILA with the
S50,01k
Gro,ww
s ith increased
Ong(,:)ing
1111�pacts all
Already
Affordable Housing
Housing Sales Tax
County through the
ecc,no,niii�c development
purchases,
implenliented
and Honnelem
Housing Fund Board
Housing Prcj,qrain,s,
Affordable
linipleniented by the
Provides,
Housing Sasles
City'. ILw
A ith the
$25k
w eased
Grc:.j,s with increased
Ongoing
all
Already
Affordable Housing
Tax
county through the
eco,no,niii�c devek:.j,pni�ent
purchases
ini)pleniuented
and Ho,ni,ele&s
Housing Fund IBo,ard
Housing (Pro rains,
Developnnent
Services, Fees,
Provide higher level of
res,p,(.:.m&[veness, for
perniff processing by
funding staff positions.
Fees niust be attributed
directly to, a providers,
1131C
W(.:),uld grow as,
deyelc:.,piv�ent grows,
Ong(,:)ing
linjpacts, specific
users,
,Can be
iivjpleni�ented
witho,ut voter
approval
'Suppe .:.jrt& crifical
attainable housing
needs
Sale r..4 ILand
Glen Cove UGA -
Expcinsicm
City intiate,d
lic),using (Evans
Vista)
Infill Devek::,iniipent
Strategy:
Exciniples include
financial,
marketing and
zoning policy, ie
tactical infill
Reduce ren' n an,
ownersh i P PICIt�enti. Ily
for housing
Expansio,n of s,ewer for
housing and inclustry..
Potential UGA swap..
More efficient urban
services based cm
existing developin,ent
patterns and p,(::)tential
Provides, housing
Housing
Non -Tax Options
with Preliminary Scoring
Es,tinmted rniarket value
$2,00,13,000 based on
esfinncited 20, lots, with net
value riff ,$'f 0,0.0'0'0'
100, acres existing
industrial. IPottenttial for
300, acres, additional
housing and light industry.
Estiincited annual $1 in in
revenue growth over 20,
year p,eri(.:),d
Ongoing annual revenue
resulting froin wc),rkforce
housing = $1 5,000/yr for
150, units. Other non -
tangible co,iiiiinfunity value
�Lr.:)wers tax burden on
residents, infrastructure.
Est S330,000, per year for
We need 75 units, per new revenue associated
year cl,n average going with ccmstructicm sales, tax
f(,),rwcird plus 40,0, units, and property tax. Also,
right now because of there is ci density tax
b,ci,cklcj,g of not enough burden reducti(.-j,n of 20�%
units being cc-mstructed for 100 ii-ifles, of water,,
over the lost 20, years. sewer, and streets.
(Current unit count per
year is 50')
hIMML
MIMMML�
Nr.:) growth potential
Growth with tirne
Inflationary gro,wth
pote,ntial. Also there
ane firnie tax revenue
Yes, depending on
density and local
'Capacity to build.
One tinne
High growth potential with
utility tax, B&O" sales, and
propert tax. Need
subarea plan tr.:) drive
density f(.:)r rniost efficient
services.
Continued deve1c),prnient
of attainable housing is
required for a sustainable
cci,miniunity
High level of sutainability
if hr using is, infill
coinipared ttr sprawl.
Ongoing with new housing
units. Will vary with
marketconclitirans, and
funding. Need tr.:) address
building cycle prr,:)blenii..
Could be for
affiardable housing..
Equitable strategy
Perceived gentrificatici,ii
,with increase business,
(:;pportunity. Cost to run
business could increase
with urban services,.
Also opportunity f ' )'r
1110re farnily wage 1".Dbs,
Provides needed
access to attainable
hcwsinq. Need {nix of
housing- TIBE),
Inf:ill is equitable. Could
i n,cl u d e pr (:),g r a in, to
achieve attainable
hr,:),u-.ing needs..
Council decisicm.
IN e i g h b,o r h
concerns to be
considered.
Requires Cr;untty
and City Cc),uncil
I
app,r(.:)Yai. IRequires,
UGA,change
apprr.-jval by
Ccmnrnerce.
RequiresCouncil
approval
Planning process,
requires Planning
CGIT111111issic.m and
City C(.:),un,cil
Seed fund c),r use
for affr..,rclable
hcwsing
Suppr..jrft hcj,using
and jr.:)bs,
Suppc)rts, critical
attainable housing
needs,
Critical need for
Ince-using b,acklr.:),g
needs, clinicite, and
insfrastructure
sustainability
3.0,8333333 1
A.33333333 I
A.66666667 1
M
Suppc;rtt diverse
Conini e rcia I
(Business Growth
Support Market
h"M;ulttifaniily
Huiusing
Reduce or
eliniiinatte ciff-
sttrreett parking
reaui reulnentts
Possible new and
addittiorlal Ic7b.s',. Makes
use of coin7nrercially
zcmed property. . Vitality
in commercial district!,
supp,ortts better services_
(improves level c::i'f
service for lic using and
infrastructure due to
iluaxerniuIll density
opportunity.
Helps with housing
density, increases cc-istt
of ,street maintenance
Housing
Non -Tax Options cont.
with Preliminary Scoring
Total grc:rss cc:rni,merrcial
activity is S450 in for the
Bitty or $1.3 rnn/acreo'f
conunnereial land space
(325 acres)..
For Example1Roc.,i'nn ttc:,,
increase a.:,i'nnumnercial
activity can land by 20,9111
which generates $'640,1k
additic:nnal annual
High revenue pccrttenttial
fc::tir market rate
aparttnuentts due to, utility
tax, sales tax, and
property tax revenue..
Not estimated yet. May
be a net zero if housing
density is achieved.
115Gl,% AMI Multi Inccrease attttaimabilittrevenue neutral , but
Family Tax of housing frrn'nn 120�Z. ttrensfers property tax
Exeniptti :)n to 154 9/6 AMI quali'f'ied costs to rest cif property
Prc-gramn houseehcafds. tax base
Growth can occur
depending coniunnunitty
apetittie for increasing
business activity and
workforce he wsing
availability.,
Cyclic based cm eccmr,.),nny.,
However, on average
very sustainable based an
A State tax structure..
Comii'mercial activity is,
what drives city revenue.,
This includes professional
services,
services, ttrades, 5,1111011
business, lmanufacturing,
etc.
High growttii pr,ttenttial
if MF developmuentt Creates long tterxnn
can be established as financial sustainability fca-r
the norm fc::r-r unit cities.,
creation..
Depends can housing N/A.
density devlecipamentt
Goal to mnaxiniJze
devek::rpmnentt of new
attainable units. We
need fig"'iim of all new
units to, be attainable h1/
or affordable_
Based cm D,ept., of
Coin nnerce 20 yr
Depends c:an lab types
Huge innprc.:weinnentt'in
equity in housing.,
Aparttnientts serve all
people at different
stages, ca -f Fife and dc:rn`tt
Equitable use of the
right of way 'for
housing purposes
Makes, housing
available for nnc:,,re
people..
lRequires, dedicated
investni ,ntt in
econoinic
developimentt and
housing
Zoning is the key
driver for raking
land available for
a pa nmentts.,
C,c:yuncil decision
Council decision
larking and
strategy
deveIopine ntt.
Balancing good
paying Icibs with
craminlunitty needs is,
the key .strategy
f:c:,r conii'niercial
growth. �ie artts
corn,munitty)
Best return on
investment Is,
aparttnnentt
rlplexes., - Strong
Towns.,
3.91 666667 1
A.5
Growtth
pottenttialfrnr housing A.16666667
density
growth potential
for housing =
>1176 eligilbe units, 3.861111
out of 1448 units,
needed by 20444
Next Steps
Financial Sustainability Task Force
Meetings continue through June
Comprehensive Financial
Sustainability Report to Council in
July
Public Engagement
Videos
uestions / Feedback
for all Teams
What is missing from this picture?
Anything you would
in the final report?
like to see addressed
Anything missing in the process?
ThankYou
Questions?
Discussion and Feedback
Hdy�
y
Figure 2. Illustrating R.-Ilzormig density cchieved.
onlycr hondfulof blocks in th.,e City cre devoeloped tofull mtended density
Stir its 4,200,
slf := 5-1 units/ricre fortotol hand area
61 un i't,s, 14'0,,0,00.sf,= ,9.71,4�ni',tslcpc,reofp,,fottlIL3d torid
with hotre s aver, ., .
. � 5` ss f ks right of w4096of the licind area