HomeMy WebLinkAbout110122 MinutesHISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMITTEE REGULAR MEETING MINUTES - Final
Date: November 1, 2022 Time: 3:00 pm Location: City Hall Conference Rm. #3 (for staff) and virtually via GoToMeeting webinar (for all others)
Members Present: Richard Berg (Chair), Craig Britton, (Vice -chair), Kathleen Knoblock, George Randels,; Kathleen Croston
Members Absent (excused): Michael D'Alessandro, City Council member/HPC liaison Monica MickHager, Walter Galitzki
Staff Present: John McDonagh, Senior Planner; Judy Surber, Planning Manager
Topic
Motions/Recommendation/Action
Chair Richard Berg called the meeting to order at 3:02 pm.
Mr. Randels requested consideration of a motion.
Randels moved to thank Surber for her work
and welcome McDonagh back. Second by
Britton. Motion passed unanimously.
Approval of Minutes
Staff suggested moving approval of minutes
7/6/21 Regular Meeting:
after New Business.
8/3/21 Sub -Committee Meeting
9/7/21, 10/5/21, 1/4/22 and 2/1/22 Regular Meeting
Approval of the Agenda
Motion by Knoblock to revise the Agenda
with Approval of Minutes to follow New
Business. Second by Britton, motion passed
unanimously.
Correspondence/Attachments:
None
Appearance of Fairness:
None
Public Comment (for any non -Agenda items)
None
New Business
Motion by Croston to recommend approval
A. HPC22-028 315 Willow St. Molly Jackson, owner; Michael Karas, Agent
to use of metal roofing. Second by Randels.
Secondary home alterations to include a standing seam metal roof.
Motion passed 4-1-0 with Britton opposed.
John McDonagh introduced the item and directed HPC to focus on the roofing material per
the guidelines. Ms. Jackson presented the proposal and her rationale for metal roof.
Currently it is asphalt shingles. Owner desires to more sustainable materials. Judy reminded
HPC members to distinguish comments "per the guidelines" from "personal preference" -
votes should be based on compliance with adopted guidelines. During discussion, members
Topic
Motions/Recommendation/Action
noted house is outside the district and other homes nearby have metal roofs. John
McDonagh noted the guidelines afford the greatest latitude to secondary residences.
Approval of Minutes
7/6/21 Regular Meeting:
Randels moved that today's minutes note
8/3/21 Sub -Committee Meeting
only that HPC had discussion on various
9/7/21, 10/5/21, 1/4/22 and 2/1/22 Regular
public processes and the committee's ability
to comment on policies and procedures of
John recommended postponing sub -committee review minutes since the two
various kinds and no action was taken.
subcommittee members are absent.
Second by Knoblock for sake of discussion.
Committee members discussed the comprehensive approach to city projects
Croston suggested friendly amendment to
proposed by Main Street and Public Works/Parks. They also revisited ongoing
concerns with approval process for public art process and their ability to contribute to
add request to discuss Public art and the
that process. Committee discussed informal discussion with Monica Mick -Hager to
Adams Street project with Mayor. Randels
relay the concerns. Britton and Croston volunteered. John will arrange the meeting.
did not accept.
Original motion—failed.
Britton moved to approve 7/6/21 Minutes
with correction of year (should be 2021 not
2022). Second by Knoblock. Approved
unanimously.
Croston moved to approve 9/7/21 Minutes.
Second by Knoblock. Motion passed 4 to
approve with Britton abstaining.
Motion to approve 10/5/21 Minutes by
Croston, second by Knoblock, approved
unanimously.
Motion to approve 1/4/22 Britton, second
by Knoblock, approved unanimously.
Topic
Motions/Recommendation/Action
Motion to approve 2/1/22 Minutes by
Knoblock, second by Croston. Approved
unanimously.
Old Business -None
None.
Other Business/Announcements:
Next Scheduled Meeting:
December 6, 2022
Adjourn:
The meeting was adjourned at 4:34 p.m.