Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLand Classification for Chinese Gardens Addition to Fort Worden State Parki ' R<c (v-7-?s l' CfiINESE GAITDTN5 ADDITION TO FORT WORDEN STATE PARK WASHSINGTON STATE PARXS & RECRMTTON COMMISSION KESOU RCE DEYELO PMENT DTWSIO N lt '1/"il\'rl /' -qLtL' /' LAND CL"4,SSIFICATION r\\I' FOR A--N",\ L' w*1 ry, J b itxi.. I (.J.I <4 tr"-i' ' ' a^..-\' i/--,:-tt'ir1-'' - ltii;it N -.{- s w CHINESE GAROENS giAl5*1Jii.*'i:::ii:;if :';;:i;'-i I-and Classificationfor C}IINESE CATTDEN5 additionto FORT WORDEN STATE PARK by: Chinese Gardens Land q1p-:lfication Comrnittee JIM IILIUPHREY JEA}T CA}'IFIELD KATiIRYN JENKS BARBARA BOGART WARREN STEURER and': Washington St'ate Parks and' Recreation Commission liltl-oeveloPment Divis ion RICHARD FANKHAUSER, CHIEF SITE PI,ANNING AND 1COUISITION lPrePared bY F'RaY) Cover ittustrates Ctrinjse Gardens ratercotor painting by Kathryn Jenks) I drir'rcsc Garto'rs Sitc OuimPer Peninsula) Z ciV ol PortTownsend2 I FORi WORDEN STATE PARK Sf RAII OF JI]AN DE FUCA ADMIRALfY IN LET wAsHr^/c roN I CH1NESE GARDENS Sitc Locatlotl Plate t 4:laclp Garbclt Lanb Clarlfuatlox TABLE OT CONTEIflTS: INTRODTICTION 1 1 3 FINDINGS... RECOMMENDATIONS... ... ': SITE IN\TESTIGATION Surface soils' characteristics, patterns" ' Vegetative cover, forest tYPe Drainage Patterns. ehysicil ?eatures, land' forms, general topography' Existing land use, surrounding uses, access Sensory consideration Recreation values, significance Photo record SITE ANALY8IS Critical resource zones and buffer areas Drainage systems and flooding characteristics overriding managiement restrictions Visual analYsis.. - tnterrelatiinships of resource and recreational values Recreational development capability Site Location... RelationshiP to Fort Worden Soil Types Vegetati-on. Drainage Basin topogriPhY, Drainage, Existing improve:nents' Shoreline Designations """' off-site Visual Access B I|ECOMI'{ENDED I,A}ID CLASSIFICATION 14 LIST OF PLATES 4 7 8 9 9 1L t-1 1_1 L2 L2 l_3 13 l-3 l-3 iA iB 6A 9A l-04 L2A L2A 13A 14A l-48 t- z A 5 6 7 o eApp IX lx nd Append Page ii 1'tln ete Garbcrlr Lanb Clarlflcatlon INTRODUCTION: Theproperty,commonlyknownaStheChineseGardens(herej.nafterreferredtoasthesile), rni"n abuts Fort Worden state Park was purchased rroro tlr. and Mrs.--ctlarres chebuhar in December 1988 for sSoorooo. The property "oni"ir= 93 upland acres and 1,430 feet of saltwater fto"["gl ott-the Straight of Juan De Fuca' The upland' acreage contains a pond. which has historically used. for surg"-i;".ring of sto-rrowater runoff by the city Townsend. following dates: March 18, 199L April 22, L99l- l(aY 21-, L991 MaY 28, 1991" June 11, L99L June 25, 1991 JuIY L6, l-991 field triP to site') This rePort was then comPleted and comment - offered for Public review and beenofPo+rt The beach and, uplands of this scenic property has in recent years been used. by rnany.for ioor density rec-realion suc'r as hiking' vrildlife oblervation "na r"fated' activities' The property continuestobeusedforthesepurposes.Nostructuresexistonthepropertyexcept-f;;-flood cbntiol structures that are used to @' regulate-th; wate? Ieve1 of the pond' The name rrchinese Gardensrr was derived' from the early 1880rs when therewasasignific.",tcni,,esepoPulationinPortTownsend.TheChinesewerelocatedi"tn"PortTownsendareatoworkonaproposea"i.irioad that never came about. The subject property was where the chinese naa-tileir gard.ens prior to deveropment of the Pond, thus the name' Asafirststepindeterrniningr.vhatfunctionswillbeappropriate on this site, this t.;;-;i;ssi.r:-c"tion study has been undertaken' The findings are to ne-consistent with chapler 352-15 WAC (WAC 352-...6-020 Land crasslr:.""iio"l . The recomrnendations wilr be forwarded. ro rhe wash;;;i;;-atit. Parks and Recreation commission for its consideration' TheLand'ClassificationCornmitteemetatFt.Wordenonthe Page 1 IFindinqs: ' l.Thecommitteefindsthatthesitehasinanearly ""a"""f"p"9 state for active outdoor recreation activities' 1'tll.etc Gat6€tl, LanO Ctarllflcatlon historicallY been used and passive low densitY 2 . The cornmittee f inds . that the in"-=it" including native flora' lit""tions of th; site and the i"i"r balances are inPortant' naturallY existing amenities of--i.rrtt. aird landform are the rr=i.in"d' maintenance of its 3.Thecommitteefind'sthatthesiteislargeenoughtoprovideusersvrithafeeling "t"rlii-ira" and tranguility, and an opportunity to vievr ''a'tott-it its rruncontrolledrr form 4.Thecom:nitteefind.sthatthereshould'bealinittothe}cinds and, intensities of u"titllli"i on the site so that there is a minirnum d,isturbance .t'tn"-"iturat features and therefore assure the maintenance of "t "ppi"xinate natural setting' 5.ThecommitteerecognizestheunigueaspectsoftheChinese Gardens marsh on the at'-e"i^ee: f-e;insuli and' the fragile nature of the wetland, vegetat-iln-in ina aro''t"a in" Chinese Gardens lake' s.Thecommitteerecognizesthatthelakefunctionsasafloodwateraetentionraciriti-u"a-"= sugh rnust have periodic mainren.r.,I"-.rrJ upgraaiiq*;; i[=-iiooa control improvenents' T.Thecomrnitteerecognizesthat_theShorelineManagementactdesignat";"i;;-inir,"=6 Gard.ens marsh and related wetlands as conservancy zor-Le, thg '=" il*"ter beach and bluf f s as Natural area ' and the r.i-ra= directly-n"ni"a the bluffs as suburban' The committee recognizes tnai - in" sunuruan ctassirication permits resid.enrial aciivity ;;;";"nittg urban density, livestock' gardens or woodlots' S.Thecoru:nitteerecognizesthatthehighqualitvviewintothesiteand. irs narural i::;;;"i::1 i"""ti6" 6r tn"'homoseneitv and unbroken visual cn.r."i"t 3t tn" =jl";= separate vegetation groupings and featurel-I""i"aing the lake, meadov, shrub colonies, and, forest.-T;;-;;nrmi€tee-t"""gtti''"= that the forest on rhe easr side is actuaiii Jii-tit"'nui-t'it"r to the integrity of the site. r ln ,hi. report the site refers to the skating Lake site only ard not the entire combined Lake area. Page 2 Ft. Worden/Skating crtlnctc C'artclr t-u'rb dagiflcat lotl s. The committee f ind.s that the existing gomr.or! 1!3parkingareainJeffersonCountylsNorthBeachPar}C- needs for parXi"g and' restrooms generated by Chj-nese users. tion and serves the Gardens shorelines be access to the trails and Recommendations : l-. The comrnittee recolullends AREA for the entire Chinese the land classification of NATURAL Gardens site Per WAC 352-L6-020. 2. The committee reconmends that the visual integrity of the site be retained ""J-piotected by naintaining.a 50 foot.9""p buffer strip of ever;;"-"; forest aiound the perirneter of the rqeadow, an6 t.r"t:-rrg i"-n"iiaj-n9s or other inprovements r^rhich would in-".topt the high quarlty visual experience' 3. The committee recolnmends that the lake and its pr"--rt"a ana-proiected !Y nroviding gnly visual - iif" and, its rllu.t"a wetllnds except for approved overlooks. 4. The committee recommends that any flood control structures placed on the site be done to mj-ni-mize visual impact on the site' This include= pr.cing them underground' or at ground level' This includes any ii'tfrott"*ents within the Suburban designation as id""i:-fied in tire shoreline management act. 5. The committee recomrnend.s continued use of !!re site via unpaved footpath provided the North Beach Park is available for parking and. Lomtoit station facilities' 2 See Flelationshio to Ft. Worden' Plate 2 Page 3 C1:tne* Garocrrr Lanb Clanrlfkattor'r SITE TN\TESTTGATTON 3 claJ-J.am gravelly sandy loan, 0-L5* (Ctg) w"ii:ataiied, wiln a vEry slowry permeabre d'errthof20to40inches.Fornedinglacialoi'tix"a coniferous and deciduous trees' Roots penetrate to a depth of 20 to 40 inches' This soil holdJ about 2 Eo a inches of later avairable for prants- Runoff is slow to medium, .rra- tn" hazard of water erosion is slight to noderate' The soil is saturated, part of the tirne during the rainy season' and at time= ;;a;; rnorl= laterarly, in places, above the cemented layer cemented layer at a titl under a forest Most of the acreage of this soil is used for growing mixed. grasses and, alfalfa or g'rass and clover' Horoe ferriei, and' vegetables are also grown' pasture of garden crops, This soi]- has very severe erosion lirnitations that reduce the choice of pranil-i"a-r.q"it" very careful management. Management i=rr"= iircruJ" cross-jrope ti11age, vegetated waterways, diversion teri.""= to inte"rcept.wai'er frorn steeper slopes' and the use of sod.-forming grassei in the cropping system to herp control erosion. suiti5fe f"rmanent pastuie pl-ants include tall fescue, orchai;:g;;;;;-ii*Lttty, ryegrass' and red and white clover. The principal species in this- soil iVn" are Douglas-fir' western redcedar, ,"4 iia"r, western hemlockr-madrone, and dogwood. Understory plants are Oregon grape' salal' evergreen huckleberry' bracken and sr+ordf ern ' This s oil is somewha t poorlY drained.. Permeability is moderatelvi1slow. Roots Pen etrate to a dePth of rnore than 60 inches.The so holds L0 or more inches of water available for Plants. Runo tt ]'s slow, and the ha zard of water erosion is sliqht. A seasonal water table is at a de pth of L to 2 feet. This soil has severe liroitations that reduce the choice of plants, reguire special "o,.l."=.,ution practices, or both. Runoff ranges from ponded or very slow to sllw, and there is littIe or no hazard of erosion' 3 S." Soil TYPes, Plate 3 Page 4 Cr'inelrc Gartcrr L*rb Cla*lflc'tlotl TheseSoilsrequireadeguatedrainagebeforemostcropscanbe., rown. Thev aiJ us"a :noJtty f or growing permanent pasture, hay 2-- and silage. A variety of srnall srainl_'_ garden vegetables, tree it,tit=, ind berry crops.are also grown successfully on them' open-ditcn anJ-lir" drains are suitable for controlling the rvater IeveI Principal vegetation species are Douglas-fur, western redcedar, red. a1der, *"=i"t" hemiock,.grlnq fir' bigleaf maple-' cherry and madrone. understory plants' iiclude salal, evergreLn huckleberi, salnonberry, thi:nbleberry, trailing blackberry, reg huckleberTy' o;A;; gt.i", red elderberry, nettles' bracken' and swordfern' This soil is somewh at excessivelY dra ined. PermeabilitY Roots Penetrate to a dePth of more than 60 inches. This holds 3 to 4 inches of water available for Plants. Runo slow, and the hazard of wa ter erosion is slight. is rapid. soil tT IS Much of this soil is used for growing 1 variety of flowers' bulbs, Lrome giid"" fruits, berries' and vegetables' Suitable pasture plants.are tall fescue, orchardgrass, ryegirass, ilf.lr., lnd red and white clover' The principal vegetation species are Dougtlas-fir, madrone, vresternhem}ock,wester''a''aredcedar.Understoryplantsare oregion graper.-irailing blackberry' rhododendron' bracken' r.igr.6n huckleberrY and salal' McMurrav and Mukelteo pgats (l'Im\ ., .r^r^.:-- a* A, These soirs affi, shallow basins or depressions' They are ver"-n""tfV-aiain"a. Permeability is moderate' Roots can penetrate to'a'deptir of more than 60 inches' These soils hold more than 10 in"nl= of water available for plants ' Runof f is very slowtopond.ed.,and'thehazard'ofwatererosionisslight.A moderate hazard. of srougning-ot slumping exists along lank.s 9f^ open drainage d.itches. a ="isonal waler-table is at a depth of 0 to L2 inches Thissoilisclassedashavingmod'eratelirnitationstha!reducethechoice "f-piu"t= or that ieguire rnoderate conservation practices. p;;;Jifity is nrodeiate to slow. Available water capacity is .t"ry hig!' Roots can penetrate to a depth of more than60inches.Runoffis-veryst-owtoponded,andthereislittteornohazardofwatererqsion' These soils requlre TheY are used mostlY and silage- Among th extensive drainage before crops can.be for permanent pasture and for growlngi p"ti.Ity crops weII suited to these girown. haysoils Page 5 d:lne* Grrtcrr Lanb Clarrlflcatl.otr are mint, veg'etables, bulbs, and blueberries. Open-ditch drains are used to control the water level. If the water below a depth of 30 inches in the deeper soils, the rate settling is accelerated. andtiletableisof Suitable petnanent pasture plants in drained areas are meadorv foxtail, taIl fescue, timothy, lotus major, New Zealand white clover, and big trefoil. Wanato siltv 'l aw I oam t'Wa) This is poorly drained soil. penetrate to a depth of more l-O inches of water available Pe:meability is slow. Roots than 50 inches. This soil holds 8toforplants. Runoff is very slow, and the hazard of water erosion is slight. Depth to the water table in undrained areas ranges from l/2 to L-L/z feet during rainy 3:eriods. This soil hds severe limitations that reduce the choice of plants, and/or reguires special conservation practices. This soil occurs on a f]ood. ptain. ff properly drained, these soils are suited to a variety of crops. They are also used for grazing stock and for growing hay and silage. They are also used for growing grains, berries, fruit trees, and truck and field crops. Adequate drainage is generally needed for all crops. Open-ditch and tile drains are used in these soils, but tile drains are more suitable. Dikes are needed alonqr low bottom lands that are subject to occasional overflow. Suitable permanent pasture plants are tal1 fescue, meadow foxtail, orchard-grass, timothy, lotus rnajor, and red and white clover. oats and rye are suitable for use as gireen-manure crops and cover crops. Principal vegetation species in this soil type are Douglas-fir, red alder, western redcedar, grand fir, western hemlock, Sitka spruce, bigleaf rnaple and willow. Understory plants include sedgres, reeds, nettles, skunkcabbage, and salmonberry- Sr.rantown oravellv I oam - O to 82 lSuB) Permeability is noderate above the cemented about L6 to 20 inches dePth. layer which occurs at This soil has vdry severe liuritations that reduce the choice of plants, and/or requires careful managenent. Permeability is lnoderately rapid above the cemented layer. Roots penetrate to a d,epth of 2O to 40 inches. A perched r.rater table is at a depth.of e Lo 3G inches during the rainy season. Runoff is slow to rnedium, and the hazard of water erosion is slight to moderate. This soil is used for pasture and for groving hay, silage, and fanily vegetables gardens. Drainage is needed in places. Open- - Page 6 1tlncae 6ar6crrr Lar'rl Clalrtficatton ditch and tile drains are used. These soils sometimes dry out late j_n sumner and early in f alr, so suppre:nental irrigation i's beneficial. Suitable pasture plants are tall fescue, mead'ow foxtail, timothy, i;tu; naj-or, and ied' and white clover principal vegetation species in this soil type are Douglas-fir' red alder, *""i"tn rea?:eaarl grana--fir' weslern hemlock' Sitka spruce, bigleli-r"pi" .tta. wifiow. Understory plants include t sed.ges, reeasl-""iii"=, skunkcabbage' and salmonberry' Veqetative Cover. Forest TvPe" Thesiteitselfhastreecoverintvo}ocations,atthenorthend along the high-bank shoreline' and pt -the south end around the small pond. t.}m"a by the ";;air J.r.o Th"=" areas are primarily evergreen rorest wil,n some d.ecid.uous and reparian tree cover around tn" poia. oorin.nt tree tlrpes are idLntified above with soil types. Trees range in size ?io' 12 inches to over 24 inches in d.iameter. t-;p;;;;= that a double row of evergreen trees were planted atong-In"--=""th edge of the- sma1l pond at about the same time as some other tree roi= were planted ltong W St'reet near the rnilitary cemetery. This sutfests intenLionar planting by the personnel at fori, Worden iiii"g early days whln the fort was used for militarY Purposes Anotrrerrowoftreesappearstohavebeenplantedtoprovidea screen along ihe west u"utta"ry of Ft- worden Park about three quarters oe tne way up rronr tire srnall pond to the saltwater shoreline.ThisrowoftreesseparatesthepresentopenfieldinFt. word,en from the open iieras-of hay in the chinese Gard'ens site. It .pp"ii=-in.t'perhaps the area was once a large grass field, all the way from Cninlse Gardens lake into Ft' Worden' The trees ,ro, u."I"ptluiv-="r""r, the Ft. worden site from view Evergreen shrub "o.r"r5 occupies the -north end of the site and extends west from tne trell to ,r"utly the furt vridth of the site' This strrub cover and the trees at thl north end are wind-pruned into an interesting wedg"-;h;;" sloping dowl towards the west' shrub cover is also rocated. along some of the boundaries and at i;";-poinis in the interior fields of srass' The shoreline and the shallow water ttol"td th" Iake is inhabited 1 5 Se€ Veaetation, Plate 4 Rose sP. Page 7 Strait o{ Juan o€ ruca i. t,, a CmC O 3CO FEET o tr SaB s 0 Wa crb'o -\ t mM a I: I I I I I I I i I I I t I I I l I I I I U) Y I Site Boundary \t Wa, SUB 49th ct Wa CmCoRm a o Fvf -) IR r-1 I o C I I I I t I I I LEGEND: Ag8...-.Agnew sllt loam' G8% Cmc.-...Ctallam gravelly sandy loam' 0'15% Mm-.--McMurtaY and Mukelteo Peat3 SaB-...San Juan gravelly sandy loam' G'87' SuB*-Swantown gravellY loam, o-8% Wa.--.WaPato sllty clay loam Plate I CHIN€sE GARDENS Soil Tqpcs 1___ -_ SaB c''$ac;rr- Grrtcrrl tahb Clatti{kAtiotr by picklerveed'6 and other wetland vegetation' The remaind,er of the site is prinalilY grassland' The hay crop from this site has been sold Lo private bidders' ffiite prays an important rore in the drainage pattern of the City of port fownlend and' the entire Quimper Peninsula. ft-is-at the low-point :l-^l.drainage basin of over ' L,2ol-acres.na-containsatlfeapproximately40-50acresinsLze.'This lake is connected to €he pacific ocean via an undergiround piplri"e between the l-ake and the straighL of Juan De il:::y';n:'*rfor in rhe pip"i1"" is controlled bv a series of valves at, various points relvreen the lake and the ocean' The original runciion Lr tn" pi;;i*".3tr9 the valves is reportedly to Iower the o'rj=ii" water fbvlf so that crops could' be qrown on the rand now undei-water. The d.itching which shows along the s.w' ' w. r and nortn-siJes of the lake was connected' to the piping so thewaterr".,"r_"ouldbenrougntdownbelowthelakebottom. Thelakecould'potentiallyreachanelevationofgft.ifthepipelin" *"ri*pi"gg;a 3nd ii-="iricient runoff occurred in the d,rainage trasinl-m" water woura then flow overland into the Strait of Juan De Fuca ""a """id' also flood' private property includ'ing o,rib"ifainqs near the s'r+' cgrner of the site' (The normal" rarJ li;;;Ii;" is approx' o'4') The drainage basin includes more than half of the Worden State ;;;k; ""*" of the. neighborhood south and. a large "t""'-lr-nousing' open space' and mixed the site. DrainageintotheS.e.cornerofthesite(frornFt..Wordenandthead.j acent neighborhood) irav"f s in a channel behind McCurdy pavilion, northeast 9f the rnititary cemetery, through a culvert und.er the road., and into " =rirr pand-contained by an earth- filled. dam at the s.e. "orn"r-oi Ln" lake.lo It then empties into the lake, -. ppit"ntly through an overflow pipe' existing Ft. of the Park, uses west of 5 (salicornia virginica) 7 S* Drainaqe. Easin' Plate 5 u s". ' Plate 6 9 Plate 6 See See Topoqraohv, Drainaqe' Existino lmorovements' Plate 6 Page 8 10 crtlnete GarSctll t^arb Clarllflcatldtl The high Point ofi the N.E- corner' the si The site is gene te is at aPProx imatelY elevation 7o at rallY bowl-s haped with sloPes ranging from fla ttoov er LOO* on thehi ghbank saltwater shoreline.The maxim um sIoP e in the area conta ining the ped.estrian trails is approx'L3z. A1I o f the site drains towards its cente r and into the lake excePt the saltwater shoreline.This dra inage into the lake then W?'exits the site and enters the waters of the Strait of Juan De Fuca via an underground pipe with related inProvernents mentioned above Surfacewaterrunofffromtheremainderofthedrainagebasinenterstherax! at its wesi"Iia"-'',ri" ^-=ii".ttay just south of the new port rlrnr"',J *nii"-frIif.=-nuilding on Kuhn Street' Anund,erground'outfallentersthesouthendofthelake'Thisis connected to an unknown =oi'tl.-ina enptie- into the existing d,rainag" cna''n"t at the "";;;; & 49tL st'' and san Juan Avenue' The site i s presentl y used for reation such as a ierated recreation walking, s itting, sunn ing, bea infornal rec ch activity, activities. Itisa}sovisuallY_us"+,byoff-sitepassers-bywhoviewthesiteresularry "r,a-lli=ia"i l. '. ;;i";i; i""i"itioir resource' A11 who travel on surrounding =t'"!t=-sucn as S;;-;;;", AdTllalty | 49|-n', and Kuhn have a pleasa'''t--"it* i"to-the'site at various points' The high qual:ilv-oi -9re_viii-i='-i"ia!ed-i"-ii= Iack of man-made structures' tl=- tt''aform and vegetation' The site serves an engineering-f"l::i?: in dealing with the waters of tne drainage l.tir,' It' d'etai''=-in"-t.tttoif 'from upland sources ".,a ,n"f;;;--f€ ont-iiitough the o''d"tgtound pipeline between the i;k;-and the strait' The Surround'ing Iand ,'=:. is primarily single fanily. resident'iaI with horses i"Loitt"a. rni-ciii"'Ii-pirt-r3rnr"r,d pubric works buirdins is ffi;;;-on tnJ ;;;t iir"snore as is the citv sewer 11 eaa Page 9 Plate 6 i I i I i l I 1 I I 1 1 I j t I. Site Boundary tr N\NN\Wetland Vegetatlon Grasses/CroPland Shrub Cover-Evergreen/Declduous Evergreen Forest 1ate + CHINESE GARDENS Vcgctatior't t 7r\ l.- -------s l l t t+ I O 2OO FEET t]la}-- i.,l : li :i" i' I 4;r''tct< 6arbcrrr Lanb ClarlfJcatl'orr treatmentplant.''Th"Jeffersoncountyfairgroundsisalso Iocated near the s'w' corner of the site' TheJeffersonCountyParkknownasNorthBeachParkislocatedontheshoreli-ne at the n'w' ;;;;;t of the site' It provides the parking and. in!-."riort =t;ti;;-for the present users of the Ail;;: c"ta""= snorerine and uprand area' Physical access into the site is by foot trails ?nfy' No vehicules "ri!l ti;; sire ;;;;pr-roi tne farm equipment needed to p"ii"aical1Y cut the hay' Itispossibletogainaccesstothe.earthdamintheS.e.corTlerofrhesfteii.-rt] woraei:i;tk: il i= it=o possible to enter the s.w. corner "i-ti" site tion agtn st. at an opening in the existing n"oilto"'' gq"ipt""L "u'' also -enter the site from 58th srreer. ,. T#=i""i; ;J;;1;Lea wetr3nd,s preclude a road or trail "onrr""iiig'"ri parts of the site' Foot trails traverse the. site prirnarily in an east-west direction. d;;-i=-or Uott-tn"-sittwttlr beach and the upland between Ft. iioia"r, ana Noiti'-i"""n Park' some lesser used foot trails poravei-J"''g-th" ril; ;;;;; and' alons the edse of the forest. AnumberofotherstreetendsalongKuhnSt.appeartoprovideootentj-al public access p"i"i= as 6'o"=--ift" pofiic works office' irost are steep and. enco";t;;-;"tlands on the west side of the site. Accord'ingtotheShorelineManagienemnt.MasterProgramforJeffersoncountyandpott-rot"s6na, washington, t!" saltwater beach is aesisnlred_ as N"t"i.il lni i";;-ji;i--ienind the beach is classified. as sgpurban, ;;a-.h; Iake with- its associated wetlands is conserv;:y:u-;;;-h"=ig""tion carries a deff,nition and a policy t"gtli'i"n fi"friiiea activities and uses' - 1z see roooqraenv, Frein?qg'-:qgtilg4Prq:'Leltg', Plde reportedly does not enter the site but is pipec t3 seth St. is the south boundary of North Beach Park' See Plate 2 14 See Topography, Drainage' & Fristing lmprovements' Plate 6 15 See Shoreline Desiqnations' PIate 7 u s"" Partial telt of Apperdh A. 6. Ohe outfall from the treatment plant Page 1,0 I Juen Dr Fucr rt-' "i Polnt l. Jl x. T.:O { Ja.6;.39',uI ea T. !O i. I I II I I I Stra!t of rl06 a l2 4 I li I 1! il i. 1 t/ ooo 2.oo{, s,ooo r€E CHINESE GAITDENS Draina5c D*sin Plxe ; 9 r 1t 1 J FORT $'ORDEN STATE PAfiK I PORT t r I S U-L 1113: ctrv J OF PORT T 0wllsEN0 E , i \a dounryBBasinDrainage liil) d,rir'rcsc G.trbcnr Sitc Fao'|' 1'rlne* Garbcr'rr Larrb Clalrlflcatlorr Sensorv Consideration winds across the site are per:i=!:i: ilu.ll"X'll"tnlli"I"ll""n m:"il":i;hlill'!h:i".F iiii::!';;r==iv"rv- increase i" heiqht from west t6 east. -wi"d= increale {'h" ""t'=" of isolation due to their'iiI,rl.ti',g .fi."i U"t*""" hik"t= and'/ot beach users' Shore}ine wave action ?9d= to the tranquility of th: area and attracts tt''u'tl-in; site' ;;";'-;lso'"d;;*;;ietv or texture and cornpacrness !oi-.".r]r;;;t' oi*i!"i"itiott experiences on the saliwater beach' ontheuplandsthetallgrasses.provid'eaninterestingsenseof touch when nirinq th:oYgl-l;; site. e'.=!..rrbignt Ylri"= from shoe height to o'!'-e-teet a.p"iil,.Iq_o' tne season. Sounds from the vrinds and grass varY ' Thesitehascleanairforarefreshingsenseofsmellovertheenrirearea "x-ept 1"u: ti"*.li.f7air"'";-in" south end of the Iake.Heretn"-clnal"""*=tohave.,,oiislick.onitandalso has wtrat appear to be ?o.iy-bubbles-ttta-t questionable odor sussesti"q ;;;; ii""=tietliot' mav be order' LakesLrore walking -is =::! and spongy on soils and plant materials which are arways damp ""i i"r.-inii--r".-n""ds protection from foot traffic' The si te serves three ma3 or recrea ti-on needs 'It Pr ovides low- banlc acce ss to the ocean shoreline for sitting,walking,sunning; the uPla nds for easY walks in a provides it provide beautY s d'aY hiking on sett-ing vrith cI for the v isual enj oyment of al I who Pass bYonbeautifulose-in destination Po ints;and it nearbY roads or who enter the site. Photo Record Slides of the site identification ' should be kept for a baseline condition Page 11 Strrlt o TEFOFT Shr BoundrrY trkc (0.4) f rt IX{ n t Contm nd.tgrcund (- Control Structun Uoderground outlall o 2oo FEfi Errlh Pond NORTH,,1ri. l: lI.t I i4 r i I I I i i I I I I Clty of Port Townlend Sowor Tre!tmont Phnt Clty of Port Townao Publlc Workt DoParlme nt a tr R I I I l I,'I oata Bas€: Aerbl SurveY o( 1975 comPilcd bY Aerial MaPPing Co. ol Oregon'Portland, Oregon: field l control bY Encon. lnc..Vancower, Wash'Contour lntoryal-2 L Mean Soa Level (MSU- MSL+4.75'=MLLVV) U.S C'& G.S. Datum. Tlxe 6 CHINESE GARDENS Topo5raPlrq, Drairra5c Ltistirrg I rtProvcrrrortr LEGEND: O 5'O FEET::- ffi ffii Natural Suburban Conservancy ADMIRALTY INLET L! uJ o u- o o I,- rt-. J r\t t _f-il.\I I iF: L" fi L:' l F d F n tIf-lt.l t- o jo"'i U o o'n lr-- Plafe t fT. WORDEN/CHINE5E GARDEN 5 Girrcsc Garbcrrs Sitc i i:'. rt,'.:'_: l::....-? 2a,r.Jllul it) r':; q # tl' t@ Ittl J,,T FT. WORDEN STATE PARK 5lrorclirrc Dcsignations C,lnlne*e Gartc-tll Lano Clagtfkatlon Site Analvsis a The Iake and entire shorel ine is , according to the L975 Washington Envrronmental Atlas,considered an inland marsh unique to the verY dry QuimPer Peninsula'Accord,ing to the Atlas, rrlt was altered bY Chinese landowners in earlY Ye ars for a large' p roductive garden,but has gienera lly gone back to a near-natural state.Countless ducks breed here ' rl The lake shoreline is covered with Pickleweed'17 and other wetland v"q"tJti;;' -rni= tt"g*ttti:1-:"?""t survive under heavy or continuedusesuchasmayletnecaseifunregulatedpublic access to tn" Iitot"ii"" i=-p"ttit!?3:..:?::"tine restrictions are a"a to keep the rnarsh'in good cond:.tron' Thebeautyofthesiteisapparent.to.allwhoviewit'.Views across the rare--ina over t;;-;;;;srand's extend' to the treeline along the..=l"tn side wn"i" €ne site joins the existing Ft' worden state park, and "1;;; iii" north-end' of the site where the trees and shrubs come netwein the water and' the viewer' The high cruality of tn;"ii"r,'-""a it=--rirg. scare combined with visual iccessibility, its naturai-"""ai€ion and peaceful appearance' its color, its texture and' its physicSl l:* are valuable' The seasonal "r,,tti',g-or-in" niy-.tia= to the variety of coror' texture and. form without d.estroyi;; il;-integrity of the siters visual appearance - N/Accordingtotheagreementbetweenthecityof.PortTownsendand the washington state-parks and Recr"itiorr tonrrnission the chinese Gardens lake can sera/;-;; a retention/detention reserroi:-:?t*""t its ',ord.inarlrrr sLze ti "ppigximately 40-45 acres' and a maxlmum size of s5 acres. wh;; lt-"-i.x" t:-;:-::1 1X"*t*ttm as:reed on size then it will be at approximatley 56 acres' When the lake is at 55 acres rn z-o rt- erevation based size, its shoreline will be on the rnaP shown on P1ate 5 ' at 17 (sal'rcornia virginica) u S." Memo of Understanding dated october 4, 1988 between Washington State Parks and Becreation Commission and the City of Port Townsend Page Lz u11Iy-.":::=i:::{::::}:':::'Hti'3?.roadsinclud'ing Ad'miralty-avenuel:;; J''u'" av-enue' 49th Street and Kuhn street,'. A spectacutar viei i=-"t"ountered when driving north' on San Juan i"a topplnS t1e ni'ff near +St}r Street' Inte::mittant views are .ttii"ui!-rt5*-eatii"rtv-1"?:;" and 4eth street' Views are availabl;-;;;;-Xunn Street on an iniernittant basis over the fuJ.l length iti*-ngln to the North Beach Park' Thecolorrtexture'andformofthegrassland'schangeswiththe seasons which includ'es qt"ii'''q-"11 liT"itittq the grasses' This provides an interesting pili"i' to viewl-fi;-naturil setting is iestful and. encourages one to pause and' appreciate it' Thela}<e,andthegrasslandsand'thicketsontheoppositesideofin" rake .'"*"i"":;1 :.y^i:i;;;:;:,:l*i.:lt"f::T1"":fl;:i""', - fioviaing an unbroken vre' thickers are i"!"t.iti-"g lr,-in.t they i;" wind pruned and provide partoftheveg"t-1!:Y:*"*iiri"tiootta'tn"-p"iimeierofthemeadow and also provi6'e variety itt th" meadow itself ' The lakeshore and related wetland vegetation protection of this resource is inportant and ige rV foot traffic' is fragile- The necessirY to avoid The Management and DeveloPment llt"=- i'neea-to accommodate i w"iJ"" Park' This rePort also tpgi"l-r'"a =Pi"* at Fort Wbrde Plan for Fort Word'en State Parkzo public usase at Fort i"ai"it"s that d'ernand for RV i"i=-""treme1Y high' The rePort 1'tlac* Garbcrr; Lano Ctarlfflcatloyt 19 See Otf-Site Visual Access' Plate 8 20 Prepared by Economic Besearch Assoc" Sept' 7' 199o' See Appendix B The siters recr eation value is intimatelY related to the existing 1and,water r vegetation and other on-site features'Its natural appea rance,f orm,and condition Pr ovides the basrs for the recre ation exper ienc e derived from visiting the site'The saltlra ter shorel ine maY be able to carrY more intense use with no appar ent dama9e'but the I ake and surround ing wetland s should be prima riIY for visual access'The current I evel of deve Ioprnent of the tr ails is adequate for the site and an ticiPated uses' Page L3 I Strall ot Juan u"- o g tr tr- qALP o o 0 fl 1S o o o o oo Y Chinese Gardens Site Boundary 3SFEETo o tr oF E t 'S late I I a n v 1' J= Li t/ D a-\L trt CHINESE GATTD€Ns o0oo o o U o Visual Access Umits I I I I o oo^ o off-Sitc Vissrl Acccss l.-' r-,ir t: t, l I l' i rl.: il t i. j.i ir 11.. j..: j I J':r- 1 1l. f r. . i., i' 1j.t: I il.i;t.'\ il I i i! t i 1 i,. ii t .- t ir ..'lr ri 1ttil: I I t I 1 t t l l il 1 t 1 I 1tly,e* Gar6car Lanb Cblrificatlor suggests that a phased' program "f l:Y"lopment of up to l-oo campsites in the^ chinesl eird.ens area night be undertaken' TheWashj.ngtonStateParksandRecreationcommission,atit'sDec.l.ggorneetingheldatrortWordenStatePark,dealtwiththequestionofcar,ping.": ilr? inir,"=" earaens property''' Although a camping study to deternri""--otn"te to locatL additional camping opportuniti"joil":"";;;:!iF bv the commission' the chinese Gard.ens property was "p""tll""irv excluded' from this study' This action was taken after "."liil.li"t with the Fort worden Advisory committee ""i'-tii"--ity or Port rownsend' Itvrasa].soagreedthat-theforestedpark}andslocatednorthwestofthemuI" ulttt f" included in t'he study' EventhoughcampingisnotnowaplanningissueonthreChinese Gardens property, it -is h;t;; noled-tna[ the only forest vegetation iI-ifcai"a i" i*"-'"tl.=.' The largest is at the northeast "oin", of the =ii". This has the potential for supporting about 25 "ttp=ii"s with an access road and comfort station and with an appro".-so ft. deep visuar forest :-YI-t"t' This buffer *""ia-i"rglry -= creen any development from vlew' however this sire is .*roo.iiiv-!"i;i=d' to other areas r*ithin the Ft. worden forest cover *nl"n'rnight,be considered for overnight camping. Thi;-incfuaes.tii"-iot"ltea park lands located northwest of the mur"';;r;.-n"i.tiv"Iv-"1""p sr-opes west of the gun battery in Ft. woraei-"i"ul" probleirs j-n lcceslinq the northeast corner of the site also' The other on-site tree cover is near the small pond end and is .L=o iwkward'fy situated when planning for develoPment. at the south camPground Natural Area' 21see washington state parks and Fecreation commission minutes of December 7' 1990' pages 15, 16, and 26. Page L4 12, 13 I Si{CREi-INE RfrAiliAGE lfrE Nt fuTASTEiS PROGRAfiN N-COUNTY AND FOR JEFFESSO PCRT TOWNSE}ID, WASHINGTCN ADOFT=D IIAPTCH 7 ' 1989 1-].o2 NAI$"F-AI, ac-jve lanosliies' 4.1O3 coNSERVAlTcg 4t,t) t1e or f:agjJe feaiu:es' eithe= nateraL oi A shore[ne Possessing o*: c'rltu=aL, tha-' c=i*J *"=i*-=:="'--*; lit"= natu-=aL state or relatjvej.y intolr,,'J o: h*-i'o=e otirer ur+ tirat for passive acri'rri-ies' r::clud.eoare-+.11T,.-=":."."1#"."ffi i:tr-"i.iy":::""s=?H:X'* con.i'itions, Sucn d'> !EllL-: ps;'lnitlon 9^'1 i -<t r Defi-altlon' Po)-1c7 Topreserve,main!af]:!jo"-:=.=..o=esilc:la-shore]jneassgallsal.resource elatively rree ,=om ?rusan irrti""t* and' to L=""ot=g:e or r:rotdbit -'hose activities -'ita< r':ght oes?cY "ti=nt=u= ti'-"="=:stici ot pi=="nt a th:eat to ,tt- or ilro!:ercY' 1 J;:J?=, j.:;-:TLTj.-?,".'.*==-.3=^;il5"=f =#.:i:+ffi="# iha t s e ns j"t:v "' ;1='3J ?;-"-*; t J L = "" t o' t* : i , 4q1penbix A (1 of z) 4,-104 SU-tstIR3A-N pe+ln{iron A:eas wi:e=e resicen-.jal ac-*ivit--g nay a-o-orcach rsbe.n den-sit11, but usu2r:Y wi:e:e iensl-ies Pe=r:t sPace io: snalL nu:nbers of ljvestcck, ga:iens, o: wood. lots. Theee ?.:eas a:e se=vei by ind-ivicuaL or ccmmun-it'-y Haie: supplies, but generaJly a:e not ljnked. w1ih u"il-itjes f=om an urban cer'te:. conme==ial- ac-jvi-Jes to ge-,/e the neeis or 'J:e irnmsdil3ls -ea a:e ccnsideredaninteg=a-lpgtof-*h.isoesiglnaSon. Pol1ry To provioe pe=manent resicentla'r and rec=eation=l a="=s out-sioe oi u=5an a, so long as oeveio.oment of t-aese a:eas provides aoequate faci''l 'itjes for sewao" a;tpo5a.l , wat€r suppiy, open silace, and -.}-e Ljke without seve:e oegradatlon to -.!te ljfes-Fgie t-irat was sought iniu.tlrtt. 4.:.O5 U'RsAN Defi:rJtioo The urDan enwiron:lent is an area of hign i-ntensitry land I:'se, iaclucinE resid.enria-1, ccllu:terci.a-1, and' inaust::al development' Urban snoreljnes shouLc be oes:-gi::ated. for high intensity use or :auJti-;arnj-1y resic'eniiaL i,eveloi:ment. Tte urban d.eslgna-ion nay ajso be ap5llied to areas of lower interr-siiy'r.se where the surlouniing i-and use j-s urban ald u:ban sesvices are avajLabie. : Da]ir-{x 1. Development i:r urba.n areas should' be nanaged so it enha':eces and ma-intains the shoreLine for a variety of urban llses, with preference given to water dependent and' water related' uses' 7ater-enJoymentu.ses -"hat provlde access to and enirance enjoyment of the siroreEne for a s'bstantia-l numbe= of perpons shorrld =]qs be giwen prior;ty in u=ban areas' F'.iqiincr rrrban inerconsistent2. Efficient utjlization of e:<is"-ing r:r'lan areas 1n a man wi-Jr -uhis progirar i-s enccr::agei before fr:.rthe= expansion into non- u:ba:n areas occlrrs 3. Pedes13,ian and visual access shouLd' be provld.ed to and along the r-"ban wate=f=ont area. Publjc access to and along t!:e wate='s eCge shor:-ld be coordinated. in a waLl<.-rray systero and l'rnked to acjac-nt erjs-Jng' or frrtr.::e wallcr'ays' 1. urban oeveJ.opment shorrld- p=cvioe for pubuc views to the wate=' Whe=ever pcJsible, tl:,e wa-te=sice of shorelile br-:-iJ-ii.ngs sbcrrld jlclu6e w-jrr-Cows, doors, a.:ld-nuo'lic a:eas tbat enhanie enjoyment .of tne shcreljne and pTesen: aI inie=esti:rE, at=ac--lwe vie;* ci ih' c,eveloP:le:1i f:cm "'Re rt='te:' AppenbixA dofz) MANAGEMENT {ry?.?EVELOPMENT PLAN ronf'wonPrrv srATE PARK c, d, o O PREPARED BY ECONOMICS RESEARCH ASSOCIATES FOR T WNSUIruCTON STATE PARKS anrri'n'EcnEnloru coM Mlssl o N SEPTEMBER 1990 Atppenbix B (1 of i) IIsHt LJ9 Aiocles Saa FrancrSc$ Sa,r Jretit rxciloo Boston nshrnolSn. D '.; FJrt LaUdCtdale Eco noml CS RES earc h Associates Al'iln:eo *illt Oilvets Jolas MANAGEMENT AND DEVELOPMENT PLAN FOFT WORDEN STATE PARK SUBMTTTED TO WASHINGTON STATE PAHKS AND RECBEAI]ON COMMISSION PBEPARED BY ECONOMICS RESEARCH ASSOCIATES SEPTEMBER 7. 199O PROJECT NO, 9S2 0(.tti0 Wrlsrrilc Br.r,lr'r.rr:i 5urrc 2':00 Los Anqitl^r ('arltvnra-9O0''l ia"t'.,.ooai i.,.', s5;'16' rECOt'lF3S'l'/r1 l-'r' i?13)d?8'1950 f'vlAryAG E ivlENT R ECO ivllvlEN DATI0 NS Thcreareneariy20rccommendationgroupswhichhavebeenformu]atedfrom the ptanning Process and from the Mission Statement' as folloi:ls' 16. Phvsical Planning Issues Several qpecific recommendations are made concerning the need for preparation of plans for new campgrounds at the "Chinese Gardens"' a parking and circulation management Plan for the park' and bcach area trafhc management' 3flelo-l -l ol. lolol 5lEl 'lulloi -l>l "l5lo.t =t -l9l;leltulol@l EIEI H slElbl Et:t:tLllxl6l l9lel Hltlal l Elfl l sl El l 'l "l716lsl il;l 'l El=lPl laltlilgl:loldl llil slrl gflrlsl ElFl;lill el;lilgilrl'ld t :t!tEl fl?lilsl lil;l=l SU a r-7 I\,1A YDE VELOP MtrNT PLAN:F1'199 I-l 999 Forsometime,thesecondcomprehcnsivcphaseoffaciliryirnprovementsatFort WordenStatcParkhasbeenirnderconsideration.ThcscPhasctrfaciliryrecommenda. tions were evaluated,-individuaUy by rlre consultant as to thek justification' FoUowing thiseva]uation,thcconsultantdevclopcdaprioritizedlistofrccommendedfaciiiry improvemenls.somcsclectedfrdmthcoriginalPhaseUgrouping.andsomenewly idenrificdbyl}rcconsuluntasnecess3'ytobestenableFonWordentoaccomrnodate NpenbixR Aoft) increased Public usage 6. Evaluare developmlnr and in-frasrrucrure foi'new carnpground facilities and interpretive traiJs' First phasc of' 50 campsites would add ovemight accom- modation for ovcr 100 Pcrsons' Schematic Site DiaeraT For referencc, a schematic site diagram of major faciiities at Fort Worden State Park follows r-9 Figuta l'l ,I SCHEMATIC SITE OIAGRAM FOB.T WOROEN 11 Recrealion and Tourisln Demandforovernightaccommodationshasledtothedevelopmentofnew hotel/motel sPace' 165 rooms wcre addcd in 1989 with an add'itional 65 planned in 1990. Demand for RV and campground space at Fon Wordcn and other facilities has alsobeenextremelyLr.igh.FonWordenbooksitssitesfarinadvanceofarriva].Many campgroundusers'unabletosPaceatFortW-orden,aredirectedtootherfaciliriesinthe area such as thc Jefferson couory Fairgrounds. the Marina. old Fort Townsend' a''d Fort Flagler- -; ffitl PORTlr---- 6 i-'.-.-- ' '1 u-r I AppenbixR $of') General Ph vsical Confi gu ra tion The 433-acre Park can be gencraily describcd in terms of ia physical configu- ration as four major areas' These includc: Uooer Level--a rclatively undeveloped area of the former military fonifica- 2. tions, at a higher elevation *ran rhe rcmainder of thc site' Lower Leve'l--thc ccnual activiry corc of thc Park' including roughly 100 O"U*r, ."mpnsing the muJtipurposc conference ccnter' pcrforming arts complei, and vacation housingliomplcx' il-4 I 3 4 IJeach Level--the lowest elevatiort level of the Park' including a calnP- ground, day-use Park improvetnents relating to the beach area' and a whar# area. Chinese (lardens Area--the newly acquired 93-acre parcel in the westem sector of.the Park, known from its historical use as the Chinese Gardens are^- This area is ecologicaliy sensitive' and furure uses irl this area are only in initial stages of Planning' Campsites for pubLic use in the Port Townsend viciniry exhibit very high occuPancy rates during the prime sulnmer season' Few of the sites are on a reservation system.oniyFortWordenStateParkoPeratesareservationsystem,andhasdoneso for the Past tfuee Years' Thcadd.idontothcparkoftheadjaccrrrg3-acrc''Chincsecardcru..proPcrry rilest of the historic ccntcr of Fort Worden providcs an oppomrniry for carcful planning ofadd"itionilcampsitesinatugilYanracrivescning.Linkcdwithintcrprctivctrai]s. whichcanprovidcaccesstothcstraitbeach,theChincscGardcnspondarca,andthc rest of the park, such a campground would bc highly anractive and in significant demand. AphasedProgramofdeveiopmcntofcamPsitesinincrcmentsof50campsttcs and a group cqlnp arca, up ro 100 campsjl-cs and two grouP camPs is suggestcd for thc ChincseCardensarcaint}rccarlylgg0s.ERAbclicvessuchaccommodationssuppon thcprimaryrnissiono6pgl.WordenStateParkasapublicparkwhichemphasizcsand o @ ul-14 Aqrpenbix R @or7 hostsgroupactivitics.Designofthenewfacijitiescanfearurecapabilitiesforopenor closed sequenlial ponions of tlre campgrounds as demand warrants for parks manage- ment, sra.fftng, and utilities services operations' 16. PHI',SlCAL PLANttiiNG ISSUES o erva t i ons Fort wordcn c'rrentJy balances nuncrous user groups and activities' campers, conference cenrer uscrs, day visitors and othcr users crurently utilize many of the park's unique feanrres. These fearures' such as the gun emplacements' beach area' and open fieids, rePresent high qua'liry recreational senings' WhiJe th;se park compon:ns' as wel] as the park generalJ'y, au:e well used, oppomrrr'ities for improvemcnt arrd directions of use exist- 7l ololal ;l€l dl,'l ,l Elg sl utl ol *l l "l dl(Ll rl -l 9l:lelurlolol> l ol ol HI EIEIolElolzltrl-l<t 6t 6t r-l t-:l tt-l zt _t -lttllXlol.sl ol rl Hlg;l l E1fl<l ol trl-l ol6l9lolol El 3l El el4ll tlalil<tgl:lslEl rl€l qltl H El€lHl lslolEl ElFl;lxl lel Elol El;lil=l ElrlelrlslEl :l6l' ol ol Jl .;l Elfltl:l u a n NumerousphysicalplarrningissuesarecurrentJybeilgdiscussedbyStateParks, FortWordenParkManagement,arrdlocalresidents.Thesebasicissues,suchasuaffil access,signage,securiry,andotherconccms'mustbeadequatelyaddressedinorderto improve Fon Worden' IrnPortant issues include: o Early defrnition of park uses to be provicied on the Cnintl" Gardens DroDeITv. Ovcr time, the surrounding communiry may frll in and oPPose any development of the ProPerq'' New campgrourrds of 50-100 sites in the trees' on the upper slope' awav from the pond' aPPeil to bc appropriate uses' as weU as narurefinterPrctive trails' Im olenren t-a-tj!L! Priori tics ln the fouo*,ing timeline for implementaiion for Phase IJ facilities, a balarrce of improvcmentshasbeensetintoeachrwo.ycarperiod.Theperiodcoveredincludestlre four biennial budget years berween l99l a'nd 1999' The improvements outlined in Prioriry l are hard recommendarions lor implementation; succeeding prioriry groupings should be re-examined bicnnially and undenaken in response to emerging public seryice needs and enterprise performance' Prioritv I : l99l lo 1993 6. Evaluare the leasibiliry oi-p,* dcvcloDment and infrasrrucrures hrn'ding for a new camPground at the nonheasr slope of the Chinese Gardens ProPerry' awav from the together with prograrn is for rwo Phases of 50 c inrerpretive trailst, R ampsites .3sh as'weU ecommended as rwo vcry largc grouP camPs v-53 Appenbix R (s of s1